Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by itsjustjoe on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @01:21PM
(#24423323)
FCoE (fibre channel over ethernet) was similar. Not only was it an amalgamation of arguably incompatible standards, but it was an unusual use case. If you needed data security / reliability, etc you could go FC. If you needed a cheap data protocol you could go iSCSI.
Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by ArchOversight on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @01:57PM
(#24423782)
FCoE was (and may still be) pushed heavily by Cisco. It was neat, being able to have your Cisco UCS devices talk to both Fibre Channel NetApp and Ethernet all on the same link.
It worked fairly well once it was up and running, and you set the QoS correctly so that FC traffic won out over Ethernet because Fiber Channel does NOT tolerate drops very well.
Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by duxup on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @02:21PM
(#24424055)
Cisco's FC solutions were always a weird effort to merge their own IP tech in here or there and it just always felt half thought through to me.
Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by ArchOversight on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @07:54PM
(#24427374)
Bugs... so many bugs in the various pieces. But I can say it was fairly rock solid once it was up and running.
Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by duxup on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:49AM
(#24431800)
Yeah Cisco's FC products were pretty buggy. I preferred Brocade.
FC is solid generally once you've got it running, the protocol kinda ensures that.
Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by duxup on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @01:30PM
(#24423450)
Yeah FCoE could be wonky. It was a pipe dream that was a no win balancing act.
I worked with some FCIP and given the right case and planning, that could work, within the right context.
Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by itsjustjoe on Thursday September 10, 2020 @12:35PM
(#24433892)
It was a cool idea in theory. One cable for everything! And then you realize that you still have to worry about power, KVM (or a dedicated IPMI), and any other potential add ons. Emulex worked on getting their chips as on board NICs, which would have been neat for that, but honestly the performance and lack of upgradability couldn't compete with add-on cards.
Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by benlivengood on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @06:55PM
(#24426868)
When the 8Gbps FC network used one color and the old routers only managed a couple 1Gbps links on the other available colors IPoFC seemed like a pretty good idea, especially when NetApp would only snapmirror over IP.
I certainly hope someone has turned that off by now.
Re:Hacking Ethernet out of Fibre Channel cards
by jandrese on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @01:43PM
(#24423615)
I managed to get IP over Firewire working once but came to the same realization. There is never a time when it makes sense to deploy it. The solution was just unreliable enough that even if it was a bit faster you'd lose more hair trying to keep it working than it was worth.
It wasn't that much of a lift for most organizations to just have an IP network for IP type traffic, and leave their high performance FC fabric alone to do its thing.
The few situations when it was done was when someone had some rando traditional IP systems that you'd connect just because, but these were corner cases / kinda forgotten bit of equipment that you just were waiting to replace / time out kinda situations.