News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by jonathanlydall on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @07:06AM (#24419696)
> My guess - 50%+ of even CAR buyers want to have a connection to their brand loyal assistant.

For me it's that I don't want to be beholden to the car manufacturers schedule of updates or choice of features. The only thing that really dated on my previous car and tempted me to look at buying a new one was things like lack of bluetooth audio and no big screen for maps.

As an example, it tends to cost extra (at least it did historically) for maps in cars, I've also heard of having to pay annual fees for updates to those maps and even when the maps are "upto date", their information is still not as good as say Google Maps on your phone. So you land up with these expensive luxury cars, with huge infotainment screens, and then people still using a smart phone with its little screen on the side with its maps app simply because it's substantially more usable than what the car provides.

Additionally, each car manafacturer has their own version of media players and capabilities all with varying amount of features. They all insist on figuratively re-inventing the wheel, and landing up with one which is still way worse than my rapidly evolving phone and its apps.

Car infotainment systems these days should be little more than a largely dumb interface to my smart phone so that for the 10-20 years I own the car, I get regular updates on its utility as my smart phone and its apps improve.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by patrickk on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @08:02AM (#24420066)
> Car infotainment systems these days should be little more than a largely dumb interface to my smart phone so that for the 10-20 years I own the car, I get regular updates on its utility as my smart phone and its apps improve.

That doesn't align with car makers incentives and business plans. Right now, all the talk is about mobility services (which don't make a profit for anyone currently) and chasing Tesla. They need something to replace spare parts and servicing, which is where all the profit is. With COVID, the EU commission fines on CO2, and the beginnings of EVs taking over (=spare parts and servicing will be reduced to almost nothing), they need a future profit generator. Except that doesn't line up with what consumers want.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by alistairSH on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @08:32AM (#24420276)
That doesn't align with car makers incentives

If does if lack of CapPlay/Android Auto prevents sales.

I won't buy a car that doesn't have them. I don't want to install more apps just for my car. I don't want to learn new systems when the native integration works just fine. I certainly don't want to pay for updated navigation when I get it "free" from Apple or Google.

For a while, that meant no Toyota/Lexus (it appears they've since caved and have native phone integration).

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by steve_adams_86 on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @09:48AM (#24420932)
This is the worst thing about my 2017 Highlander. No idea why Toyota thought that infotainment system could compete - it’s pretty terrible.

I’ve seen videos of people installing CarPlay compatible head units while maintaining all of the original car features, but it kind of spooks me. I’ll have to build up the courage to make the switch.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by RandoHolmes on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @11:02AM (#24421786)
If you're going to have the car for 10+ years, why in the world would it be a problem to learn the system in it?
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by ska on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:34PM (#24422772)
a) many people dont' keep cars that long b) the system is probably poorly designed and implemented
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by RandoHolmes on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:56PM (#24422999)
You have no argument here.

the average loan for a new vehicle is 3-5 years. Is it your belief that you're likely to default on that loan, therefore why would you learn the system in your vehicle?

The average ownership length for a car is roughly 6 years. Taking the time to learn a system that you'll have for anywhere from 3-6 years is completely reasonable.

This is the very definition of #firstworldproblems.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by ska on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @01:16PM (#24423256)
I don't think it's that hard to understand. People want cars to be compatible with their phone system because it's easier and it works better.

You certainly can learn the lousy interface in your car and there is some value in that, but it isn't hard to understand why the sales & marketing team is emphasizing that you don't have to (whether or not true in practice).

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by jonathanlydall on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:21PM (#24422618)
Yep, I'm pretty sure that's the reason, they're having to be dragged kicking and screaming to give consumers what they're asking for.

Every time I took my car in for a service and would look at cars on the showroom floor, I would ask about Apple CarPlay options and tell the sales person how I have no inclination to buy a new car until the current one becomes problematic or the new ones have the option of me not having to rely on their not great UI for the lifetime of the car.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by janlaureys on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @07:47AM (#24419968)
My parents recently bought a Peugeot 2008 with a very crappy infotainment system but it doesn't matter really because it supports Apple Carplay so now it has onboard Spotify, Waze and Google Maps.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by criddell on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @10:16AM (#24421214)
Porsche did something I thought was pretty smart. They introduced a line of radios with Car-Play functionality for their cars going back to the 1960s.

https://www.porsche.com/international/accessoriesandservice/...

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by Causality1 on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @07:54AM (#24420015)
I agree completely. All I need are manual stereo controls and a nice spot in the middle of the dash to mount my phone without blocking air vents or windshield.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by RandoHolmes on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @11:01AM (#24421765)
> and no big screen for maps

One of the reasons I haven't bought a new car is because I pretty actively don't want a touch screen in my car. It just screams unsafe to me, and all the research I've seen coming out recently agrees with me.

I don't want to have to stare at my console just to change the radio channel, to turn up the A/C, etc. It's insane to me that people think this is a pro instead of a negative.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by rstupek on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:00PM (#24422396)
You don't have to stare at the screen in a Tesla to change the radio or turn up the A/C, those controls are on the steering wheel.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by RandoHolmes on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:24PM (#24422656)
Here's what I actually said, with added emphasis.

> I don't want to have to stare at my console just to change the radio channel, to turn up the A/C, ETC.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Et_cetera

> et cetera is a Latin expression that is used in English to mean "and other similar things", or "and so forth".

I'm sure this will come across as harsh as it's meant to be, but you went after a strawman so fair is fair.

My actual point is that if you're doing ANYTHING while driving that involves staring at a touch screen to ensure you touch the correct part of it, often multiple times as you hunt through menu's, then it's less safe than not having the touch screen.

This point is not invalidated because you can change the volume via your steering wheel.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by LordDragonfang on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @03:16PM (#24424710)
The fact that you're using the actual radio at all puts you in the minority of new car buyers. Pretty much everyone I know under 30 just plays music or podcasts off their phone (which is an even tinier touchscreen). I don't see that trend reversing anytime soon.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by jonathanlydall on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:16PM (#24422546)
I agree that controls for things like AC on a touch screen are a terrible idea.

I use Waze all the time as it shows speed limit and warns of road blocks by cops (which are notoriously corrupt where I live).

But for a lot of cars in my experience, the screen is only used for infotainment in which case I would love to have Waze to show on it. I always plot my route before starting to drive so I have no need to touch the screen during the trip.

Fortunately push-to-talk and volume control buttons on steering wheels is very common these days, so I don't need to touch my screen to skip tracks (or switch between pre-programmed radio stations), change volume or initiate a hands free phone call. Siri activated by the push-to-talk button is also good enough to use to message back to people you're driving and will get back to them later, or tell your spouse you're on way to them now.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by joncrane on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:56PM (#24423002)
I still don't want Waze on my car's screen because it sits low in the dash. I intentionally mount my phone such that it's high up and I can still see the road while looking at my phone.

It's absolutely less safe to look down and away from the windshield in order to navigate.

It's a fine balance between restricting the view slightly with a smartphone holder vs keeping both driving and navigation in the same approximate line of sight.

But it's better than looking down and to my right to navigate (or change radio stations, or adjust climate control, etc etc)

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by RandoHolmes on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:26PM (#24422669)
If interaction with the big screen were purely passive then I wouldn't have an issue with it. The problem is that it's a touch screen and is, by definition, not passive.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by jonathanlydall on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:56PM (#24423004)
For the way I use the screens, to all intents and purposes they are passive while I'm driving. I don't have a need (or want) to touch them at all while the car is moving. I set up my map route before I pull off, often on the phone before I get in the car, then that's it for the rest of the trip.

Controls for everything else like AC, volume, switching radio station/track is not needing to be done with the screen, it's all through classic buttons/knobs or steering wheel controls. I would not buy a car which required the screen to be touched for these things.

I don't see anything objectively more or less dangerous about operating a radio in this way, the only real difference is that instead of your radio frequency being visible through 7 segment displays, it's now on a high resolution display.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by RandoHolmes on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @01:01PM (#24423073)
> I don't see anything objectively more or less dangerous about operating a radio in this way

In my current vehicle I can change stations without taking my eyes off the road, I don't feel as if I'd be able to do that if it were on a touch screen due to the lack of tactile feedback.

Also, I've rented a few vehicles and I've never seen one that didn't have things like A/C on the touch screen, which is part of why I've formed the opinion I have. OTOH, what I've rented are minivans, where A/C is a bit more complex since it will often have a "driver/passenger" dichotomy as well as a "front/back"dichotomy.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by semi on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @09:28PM (#24427966)
Not to be a shill but you should look into Mazdas. They feel similar to you and have removed touch screens, and the since you don't need to reach it they then moved the infotainment screen further back and higher up so you don't have to take your eyes off the road as much.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by peotryn on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @04:31PM (#24425592)
There are brands that have not lost their mind. Many new cars do keep physical controls / buttons / dials for A/C and other stuff out of the touch screen. If you want to dial radio when having navigation on the screen, it might be a different story, though.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by leetcrew on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:29PM (#24422712)
I have a car from 2017. it has a modestly large touchscreen with android auto / apple carplay support, but it's old enough that most of the basic car functionality (lights, A/C, seat heaters) is still implemented in hard buttons. this is the sweet spot, imo. if desired, I set up navigation and queue some music while parked. there's no need to interact with the touchscreen while the car is in motion. I do find it much nicer to have maps on an 8" infotainment screen than on a tiny phone screen with a mount that's suction-cupped onto some part of the interior. it's not so great to be worth buying a whole new car over though. as long as you have bluetooth in the head unit, a phone in a mount with a charger is still pretty good.
Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by RandoHolmes on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @12:57PM (#24423026)
yeah, if it were passive only, I'd 100% be ok with it. Being able to slap the map up on the larger screen is a definite win.

I just don't want to be interacting with it in a touch screen way while driving.

Re:Amazon demands we correct an article refering to an Echo ... by the_other on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @11:51AM (#24422316)
It’s a pro the same way web apps are a pro: cost to manufacture & deliver.