Re:Sid Meier: “I don’t think I could make Civilisation today”
by KTallguy on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @05:55AM
(#24419277)
> Firaxis's Beyond Earth has barely 1 person who played at least 1 minute for every 10 that bought the game. 9/10 buyers just handed over money out of nostalgia, never playing a minute, nostalgia was and remained the only compelling association with that product.
I bought Beyond Earth for full price at launch out of nostalgia for Alpha Centauri (of course).
Unfortunately it had many flaws:
- Much less interesting art direction and characters than Alpha Centauri.
- Gameplay was very one note, with little meaningful deviation from a few defined paths.
- On release, when you finished the game it showed a "finish game" button which unceremoniously dumped you back to the title screen. No opportunity to see stats or review your empire.
My impression was that it was rushed and had a limited budget, and I never felt like revisiting it. As sibling comments note, there is a sizable niche of mostly PC gamers looking for meaty experiences, and I believe Beyond Earth failed on its own merits.
I bought Beyond Earth for full price at launch out of nostalgia for Alpha Centauri (of course).
Unfortunately it had many flaws: - Much less interesting art direction and characters than Alpha Centauri. - Gameplay was very one note, with little meaningful deviation from a few defined paths. - On release, when you finished the game it showed a "finish game" button which unceremoniously dumped you back to the title screen. No opportunity to see stats or review your empire.
My impression was that it was rushed and had a limited budget, and I never felt like revisiting it. As sibling comments note, there is a sizable niche of mostly PC gamers looking for meaty experiences, and I believe Beyond Earth failed on its own merits.