Re:Attitude does not scale
by ColinWright on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @05:45AM
(#2441414)
That would deprive you of what I see as one of the greatest benefits of HN - exposure to ideas outside, but related to, your specific area of interest. I've found many interesting items that I would never have sought or subscribed to.
Re:Attitude does not scale
by jefffoster on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @05:58AM
(#2441449)
That's true and I guess that's the biggest challenge of implementing such an idea. Given that I like X,Y,Z would I also be interested A,B and C?
This sounds like Reddit's approach of creating sub-reddit's for different topics (e.g. proggit). This works very well in terms of filtering content.
It doesn't solve the quality of discussion issue, but it does filter the audience which offers some improvement. The quality of discussion varies highly on Reddit -- popular posts are inundated with juvenile comments, while highly focused posts occasionally have decent discussion.
Re:Attitude does not scale
by jefffoster on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @11:36AM
(#2442720)
You could apply the same techniques to comments. Voting up comments I enjoy reading would promote comments I like (and hopefully drown out the ones I don't). Whether this would look at the contents of the comments or just increase the weight of the commentator is up for discussion.
My favourite kind of posts are big data, web app architecture and functional programming. If my view of HN was skewed by my interests, then my perception of the quality of HN would improve. Chances are that other people would fit into my interest groups and hopefully that would promote tighter, smaller groups and perhaps the quality would increase.
Stackoverflow's tag system seems to work well, but assigning tags would introduce extra burden on people (and another area for disagreement). I like the idea of a machine learning approach where I see articles based on the content on previous articles I enjoyed (via voting). The same could work for comments. Going further, perhaps this could even suggest people with similar interests to yours.