Because of great lobbying by Intuit. This planet money episode goes into the details: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/04/03/709656642/epis...
Same answer of course.
"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration."
I sent in X amount. We were good.
I had one of those, and it specifically identified the error. When I went and checked the paperwork, the figure in the letter was precisely correct.
My state had developed a free filing system and had successfully tested it with selected tax filers for a couple of years. It was due to go live the following year for all state tax filers. Intuit and others successfully lobbied the state legislature and newly elected governor to ban the state from moving forward with deploying a solution.
> Under a longstanding agreement with the IRS called Free File, Intuit and other tax prep companies promised to offer free products to most Americans; in exchange, the IRS agreed not to create a free government tax filing option that would compete with the industry.
"Fix it" only makes sense for bugs. It doesn't make sense for features. TurboTax, accounting firms, entire professional organizations (CPAs) live off of the fact that the tax code is hard to understand. Maybe it needs to be difficult to properly align incentives. Maybe it doesn't. But it's absolutely intentional.
Fixing the US health care system would probably also destroy quite a few jobs in health insurance and medical billing.
It turns out overcomplicated and wasteful systems also make jobs. So even if fixing the system would be better for society in the long run, all the lobbyists have to say is "doing that will destroy X jobs" and the politicians will be scared into inaction.
Because capitalism blah blah. The government isn't supposed to compete with businesses.
It also seems like most software engineers won't qualify for free file anyway, because it has an income limit of $69,000 a year as far as I can tell.
One thing I genuinely wonder, at what point will digital/web-based services become the default for handling information by the government and every other large institution? Will it ever happen in my lifetime? Why are we still having to pay for 3rd party software to fill out physical forms? Even docusign, while it has become very prevalent for most contracts these days and is very convenient, is still requiring that you fill out a scanned image of a physical piece of paper, instead of just making the contracts web-based. Why?? Why doesn't the IRS just have a web app like turbotax for everyone to file taxes through? And if the answer is that the tax code is way too complicated that it's prohibitively expensive for the government to build a site as comprehensive as Turbotax, then fix it!