You said it yourself: they're guidelines. I'm glad there are humans in the loop to exercise judgement when the guidelines may be giving a funny results.
> We need a more algorithmic index, not one ruled by one central committee.
IIRC, there already are many "algorithmic indexes", but they're not the S&P500 and there's no reason for the S&P500 to be one.
What if they exclude a company because of political ties to communist regimes? Or ESG concerns? To me neither of these is acceptable. I would be pretty annoyed if Exxon was excluded from SP500 because they contribute to Global Warming.
Go pick another index is not a defensible position when I'm criticizing the index's policies specifically. Yet to hear good reasons for why a committee "exercising judgement" is a good thing for the average investor.
If you think a more algorithmic approach would be better you could start one — perhaps you could even get into yc with it, though historically the index publishers themselves don’t make a lot of money directly.
We need a more algorithmic index, not one ruled by one central committee.
Wonder if there's an ETF that simply does market cap weighting and just picks top public companies by valuation.