There is little to know, it's largely a commercial preference (that has, over the years, driven technological research; see ADSL for example, the first A is for Asymmetric).
Average consumers are precisely that, consumers: they rarely upload anything, but they download tons of content (from webpages to streamed media). So it makes sense for residential ISPs to maximize downstream bandwidth, since it's what consumers will evaluate them on. One way to do that is to simply throttle upstream, to ensure resources stay available for downstream. (This has the side benefit of reducing headaches, i.e. less people distributing questionable material on your network...).
If you need good upload speeds, you simply have to talk to your ISP.
Something else is the router AT&T requires will not completely open ports for you. What it does is it is closed for incoming connections that do not hit it multiple times then it opens up, so I appear like my ports are not open on AT&T. But even when I get around that (you can rip the certificates off of the router) AT&T itself limits the connection. If you transfer too much on one port on the backend they will remotely block the port sometimes. (Transferring too much being very little here, around 50MB, maybe even 10MB.)
Good news is Comcast does not pull this crap and has fiber internet. Bad news is they start at 2gbps and start at $210 a month in most areas. I'm paying $60 for AT&T gigabit.
I just got it last week, coming from the slowest ADSL option available, it blows my mind.
Do you have a source on this? I believe you I just want to know more. It explains a lot.
I have a gigabit link. I can download torrents at almost line speed. But I can barely get uploads past 5K/s. I spent hours at one point trying to tweak every possible setting and eliminate every bottleneck, and still couldn't get past 5K/s.