News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask PG: Can we see the response to the HN changes? by fluidcruft on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:08PM (#2439304)
As a PhD and researcher that occasionally sees articles on HN in my field, I can tell you that correctness of a comment's content can be independent of comment karma. I have seen 100% correct posts downvoted to oblivion with highly rated 100% incorrect responses by users playing some sort of formal debate game nonsense. In my pre-HN-bankruptcy account, I used engage and try to correct these discussions, but really it's just not worth it and once I see it starting I just skip the thread. Since that's how it works for posts related to my field, I have to assume the same holds for others that are not my field.
Re:Ask PG: Can we see the response to the HN changes? by klochner on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:46PM (#2439482)
The score doesn't have to be perfect to be helpful.