News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Nursie on Saturday September 05, 2020 @09:06AM (#24383235)
Exactly this. It's a lovely dream, but humans are lazy, aquisitive, and many would sell their own grandmother to gain a perceived advantage.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by shadowgovt on Saturday September 05, 2020 @09:20AM (#24383317)
I don't even think many would, the problem is that it only takes a few. The damage that a dedicated antisocial hyperminority can do to a society that lacks rules and enforcement of said is significant... Even more so in an age where technology acts as a force multiplier.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:36AM (#24383832)
The idea of how an anarchic society would be run is that you would need strong social norms, and people willing to use violence in order to prevent authority from rising, which effectively deals with small antisocial minorities.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Nursie on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:24AM (#24384230)
And where in the world has it played out like this?

Instead of examples of peaceful anarchism, the history of the world is full of examples showing that those with the will to use violence use it for their own ends, form gangs, and militias, become warlords...

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:26AM (#24384252)
Sure, the Zapatistas, the Apoists, and a few indigenous anarchist groups.

Forming gangs and militias is difficult when the status quo is good for most people resulting the majority being willing to use violence to avoid being ruled by gangs and warlords.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Nursie on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:51AM (#24384445)
The zapatistas amd apoists appear to be effectively democratic militia, existing in opposition to outside oppressors.

The body of your post there seems effectively to be historically illiterate.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:58AM (#24384505)
They are indeed directly democratically run militias, but that is exactly how anarchists would run a militia.

And they aren't just militias, they also run civil society.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by shadowgovt on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:01PM (#24384535)
At that point, how does the definition of anarchy vary from the definition of democracy?
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by sudosysgen on Saturday September 05, 2020 @12:45PM (#24384915)
It's certainly a spectrum from representative democracy to direct democracy to anarchy.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by lucb1e on Saturday September 05, 2020 @01:57PM (#24385504)
> the history of the world is full of examples

The written history, the recent past. We can observe settlements from the past but know very little about the time before farming because there were few or no settlements, which is not actually that long ago. This "will to use violence use it for their own ends, form gangs, and militias" might only be because we ran out of resources and space and shifted from "mother earth provides" to "this is mine". At least, that's what a book I'm reading hints at, but again, it acknowledges very strongly just how little we know.

There isn't a going back to before possessions, obviously, but I'm also not convinced that a majority of us are dishonest by nature. Certainly enough that we need laws and enforcement, but what would happen if we manage to get to a point where there are enough resources for everyone and automatic systems do most of the necessary work like making food? Do we still need the same level of security just to protect ourselves from a few sadists or could we have a more anarchistic society? Can we embrace some of the ideas that those unhappy with our current society propose?

Honestly I feel like most of this discussion is a definition issue. One person will say "anarchism is great" or "that isn't what anarchism is, you have to picture it this other great way" whereas another will make different assumptions and conclude it's ridiculous. It's a bit like being in a communistic country talking about switching to capitalism and arguing that human nature's greed can't be trusted or something. Rather, it might make more sense to propose incremental changes rather than talk about a completely different society where (if we're all being honest) nobody really has any friggin' clue if it'll increase median happiness.

One thing that is clear from history is that forming groups is bad. Making this about us vs them (anarchists vs <insert other group>), left versus right, etc.) inherently causes disagreement when I think most everyone's goal is increasing the common good.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by shadowgovt on Saturday September 05, 2020 @04:07PM (#24386501)
> One thing that is clear from history is that forming groups is bad.

Dividing groups and pitting them against each other is bad. Forming groups was the innovation that set our primate ancestors apart from their solitary mammal peers. None of us are as strong as all of us.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by lucb1e on Monday September 07, 2020 @02:04PM (#24401232)
Humans vs competing species is different from humans vs humans, though. I think it's within our capacity to learn to do only the latter, provided there are enough resources to at least have a reasonable living. We'll need to make the 'western' lifestyle require only one earth for everyone.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by FranzFerdiNaN on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:59AM (#24384025)
This behaviour is most definitely promoted by capitalism, so I wouldn't be so fast to make it a general principle. In fact, all proof shows that humans are extremely cooperative and social when the going gets tough or disaster strikes.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Nursie on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:17AM (#24384157)
Humans in general are, but a significant enough minority are interested only in power and aquisition. I'm sorry but this is a pipedream.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Barrin92 on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:46AM (#24384408)
I think it's really telling that this disaster-anarchism argument comes up so regularly. The question isn't how society functions during a state of exception, it's how it functions on day 2 after the excitement is over when things go back to normal.

It's like all other revolutions having failed the revolution has now been outsourced to hurricanes and floods. if you want to argue that capitalism or the status quo or whatever is bad, make the case how anarchism functions on an ordinary, boring day, that is to say how it organises regular life, that is the relevant question.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by tomp on Saturday September 05, 2020 @05:08PM (#24386851)
> humans are extremely cooperative and social when the going gets tough or disaster strikes.

2020 being a great example.

Jesus, this whole discussion is such a shitshow. Every time I hear about anarchism I keep wishing someone would explain to me how it all works, I expected a lot from HN users, but all I keep reading is fairy tails with obvious holes the size of Mount Everest. Like, did anyone even consider to think how you'd resolve the obvious market fallacies (which, despite the name, have nothing to do with capitalist markets, but simply with humans / rational self-interested agents).

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by fallingfrog on Saturday September 05, 2020 @09:18AM (#24383303)
Nobody aside from hardened sociopaths would do that.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Nursie on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:19AM (#24384180)
It was an exaggeration. But there are enough humans who are not interested in fair behaviour, but only getting ahead at almost any cost, that the idea of an unregulated world is laughable.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by shadowgovt on Saturday September 05, 2020 @09:22AM (#24383327)
How many hardened sociopaths can an anarchy sustain before it either collapses or becomes a mockery of its own self-direction and mutualism principles?
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by vidarh on Saturday September 05, 2020 @10:49AM (#24383940)
Is it not a good thing if there are no structures in place for those people to abuse to oppress others? We've seen states captured by murderous lunatics time and time again. It seems having structures in place for those kinds of people to abuse has worked very poorly.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Nursie on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:20AM (#24384189)
They will build structures. These structures are called gangs, and their leaders warlords.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by vidarh on Sunday September 06, 2020 @10:50AM (#24391713)
Or states.

As long as the concentration of power in the hands of nation states have been the foundation for most of the worst mass murders in human history, it seems quaint to worry that people arguing for making power shared and collective rather than allowing it to be concentrated will do worse.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Nursie on Sunday September 06, 2020 @11:48AM (#24392150)
In democratic states power is shared and collective. That's the point.

They will do worse, look around you at wherever there is a power vacuum. What follows? Violence.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by vidarh on Monday September 07, 2020 @03:06AM (#24397237)
Power is concentrated and delegated top down. That's the point. If I want to withhold consent to be policed a certain way, I can't, even if I only e.g. live and interact with people who similarly want to withhold consent (nobody would suggest that I would have the right to unilaterally dictate the rules if I interact with others who don't share my views).

So the problem is that the power is not collective other than the power to vote for who the power will be concentrated with. There's a massive disconnect there where, e.g. if we go by US elections, about half the population at any point are ruled by a system they have not consented to.

That is not collective power, at least not collective and shared power of the people, but of a majority at most (even assuming representatives do what their voters want them to, which is also a dicey proposition). Nearly every government in the world tries to limit this tyranny of the majority by legally protected rights to secure the minority against government overreach too, but the fact that they need to demonstrates how flawed this model is.

You assume a power vacuum, but nobody is suggesting a power vacuum, but power mediated by consent, negotiation and bottom up delegation rather than top down coercion.

As long as you're assuming a power vacuum, you're arguing against a strawman.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by Nursie on Monday September 07, 2020 @05:03AM (#24397890)
We have power mediated by consent. You cannot have individuals opting out of a societal system of laws or murderers will do just that.

> If I want to withhold consent to be policed a certain way, I can't, even if I only e.g. live and interact with people who similarly want to withhold consent

What do you think countries are?

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by vidarh on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @05:00AM (#24406537)
We have power enforced without any of kind of consent. We get to vote for our rulers, and ~half of us get ignored any given period. There's no consent there.

Your example of murderers just reinforce that you don't understand the ideology you're arguing against, and opt for arguing against strawmen instead.

You can have people opting out easily without the extremes you suggest. E.g. a murderer can not reasonably "opt out" because they "opted in" the moment they engaged with someone else without their consent.

Again the key is consent, bottom up organisation and voluntary association, not relinquishing all means of protection.

A more reasonable example would be that it is coercive to deny others the freedom to choose what they ingest. Even if it's drugs you don't like. If you want to organise on a small scale a drug free commune, that'd be reasonable. If you try to expand that to a country, it becomes coercive and unjust be nature of forcing massive upheavals of peoples lives, and enforced monopolies over large swathes of land if they don't want to live like that.

Which brings us to this:

> What do you think countries are?

Structures I have no ability to withhold consent from without uprooting my life and/or subjecting myself to another, which unjustly claim monopoly on power over large parts of land. Reject property rights, and by extension territorial claims of states comes part and parcel with all left-libertarian ideologies.

The coercive nature of the relationship means there's a power balance that precludes any reasonable claim of consent.

This highlights the typical left/right view of de facto rights vs. de jure rights. The ability to leave a country confers me de jure rights to extricate myself from the rule of a given state. But de facto I have no ability to find anywhere that provides the freedoms I want, because nowhere exist where they are available. A right wing view is that the existence of the de jure right means I am free. The left wing view is that the de facto barriers to achieving the goal means that I am oppressed, because real world abilities trump theoretical possibilities any day.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by shadowgovt on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @02:01PM (#24423848)
> A more reasonable example would be that it is coercive to deny others the freedom to choose what they ingest.

It's an excellent example to consider, since vaccines are in that category and some people's free choice to not take vaccines impacts the health of people who cannot take them for reasons of medical complication and now cannot rely on herd immunity to keep them safe.

> Reject property rights, and by extension territorial claims of states comes part and parcel with all left-libertarian ideologies.

While I like those ideologies for their moral purity, I think they fail in practicality for the reason you've just described: they're unstable. Another group with organized use of force and a willingness to take and hold territory displaces them, and then they get to define their actions as just in their moral framework, regardless of what the libertarians think.

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by ModernMech on Saturday September 05, 2020 @09:38AM (#24383423)
How many hardened sociopaths can any system take before the same? Look at America right now, with a narcissistic psychopath installed at the highest level of a supposed democracy.
Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by shadowgovt on Saturday September 05, 2020 @11:58AM (#24384504)
Systems built on mistrust of human nature (i.e. checks and balances) can take more.

The amount he hasn't been able to do in that position is testament to that. Imagine if the US had been an anarchy instead and he'd amassed enough same-thinking folk to take it over?

Re:Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000) by lawwantsin17 on Saturday September 05, 2020 @09:30AM (#24383384)
You should read about how Anarchy treats it's mentally ill before you decide they don't have a solution to that simple problem. The way we treat mentally ill in Capitalism is a crime.