Apart from attempts to lower Thiel's status, what value do you believe your comment adds?
Evidence that this guy has other ideas that are more clearly bullshit keys me in that, no, I don't.
This is equally true for the stereotypical west coast HN liberal.
You know the "Mom Test" for software? Is your software easy enough to use for you mom? If not, then you probably have work to do.
Try the same with your ideology, whatever it is. I know libertarianism (especially Thiel's brand) fails pretty spectacularly.
Tribalism/racism, cash for votes or "everyone gets a pony" are all pretty easy to sell. Does that make them right? Maybe, if you define "success" as "inflicted on the greatest number of people". In that case, contemporary Chinese fascism is the most successful ideology in the world, and yes, Thiel's brand of libertarianism fails.
It's important to note that a lot of libertarians' ideas about freedom and pretty much everything else is comically out of step with how most people think. They think it is because they have stumbled on the magical answer to everything (the response to any problem facing society is a trivial "no government") and that everyone else is a blind idiot, when in fact they are an odd fringe that is unlike most other people.