They used Facebook, Twitter and YT for propaganda and Gmail for coordination (that thing about saving a mail draft on gmail instead of sending it), it's obvious the other side isn't using logic to make the argument (but beliefs, feelings or simply pushing an agenda) so using logic to argue back is pointless.
I really do not think that anyone is going to reject Matrix as a solution because ISIS used them, they will have a whole host of other perfectly legitimate reasons to reject Matrix. It only makes sense to take on the additional cost burdens of a decentralized solution if your organizational needs require it, otherwise it is a waste of time and you run the risk that your effort becomes one of those shitshow horror stories that turns into someone else's reason not to use a decentralized solution.
I mean, I don't think I'm entirely ignorant of the benefits of tech shibboleths like anonymity or decentralization, but, as the internet has matured, I have become more aware of, and concerned about, the drawbacks.
So I would start by making a mental inventory of valid concerns, first. Then, in discussion, you can contrast the pros and cons, rather than evangelize only. That approach is generally the most persuasive.
You don't talk to the press without PR support. You are not honest in public to limit the angle of attack on your person... there are numerous things that will cause problems other. Ask a celebrity. A non anonymous social network tends to create 2 minute celebrities that can be quite the huge mental load.
This problem is magnitudes more applicable than some terrorist propaganda. I am a net power user, mostly anonymous in decentralized networks. I have never seen ISIS propaganda, child pornography or drug trades. Most people are probably groomed outside of the net.
Not that I'm noble enough to actually manage that, in real life. It's just, what I would do, if I had sufficient self-discipline.
(Invented though likely stats): 90% of terrorists smoke cigarettes. 98% of terrorists have drank a sugared drink. 99% of terrorists have eaten meat. All of these are avoidable.
People can actually distinguish between the two which is the reason that as funny as argument is, it does absolutely nothing.
You may seeming win debate, because people stop to engage. But, you wont convince neither on rational nor on emotional level, because that argument is weak.
I mean ISIS uses the public internet and Facebook as well and neither of those are getting the same stigma for people being disparaging about Matrix or TOR or whatnot.
Also, that’s big media’s claim against torrents. And the war on drugs started by Harry Anslinger was basically started along those lines.
It seems “percentage of use by people we don’t like / for purposes we don’t like” plays a big part.
If I’m pitching Matrix as an alternative to Slack, and someone brings up the fact that ISIS used one of them... what’s the response? Decentralized software is scary to someone fearful of shadowy groups. How do you successfully advocate for software that can be used by anyone, even the worst people out there?