This case is about a CA state law, so Amazon case would not apply.
i haven't looked into each case in enough depth to have formulated an opinion yet, so i'm hoping we hn'ers come to some conclusions on that question together. =)
I think when there is a unanimous decision, you can’t just jump to that premise. Remember, the job of the Supreme Court is to interpret the law. Laws can be bad or unjust (without being unconstitutional) and the Supreme Court will go with what the law says.
The case that the Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday turned on the meaning of a 1947 law, the Portal-to-Portal Act, which says that companies need not pay for “preliminary” or “postliminary” activities, meaning ones that take place before and after the workday proper. The Supreme Court interpreted the law in 1956 in Steiner v. Mitchell to require pay only for tasks that are an “integral and indispensable part of the principal activities for which covered workmen are employed.”
So, if someone disagrees, it seems as if their beef is with the 1947 law rather than the Supreme Court. While I'm sure there are grey areas, there isn't any real disagreement that, in general, workers aren't paid for getting dressed and commuting for example.
ADDED: From a lay perspective somewhat related would seem to be the question of whether workers are "on the clock" when changing into work clothes and protective gear. And the answer seems to be only to a limited degree. (Basically yes for special protective gear but not for work clothing in general.)
https://blogs.orrick.com/employment/2014/02/05/get-paid-for-...
My first thought when reading that phrasing is: if we assume that the security checks are NOT integral and indispensable, wouldn't that imply that the employees are free to skip those steps?
Or, from another angle, are there any limits on what activities are defined by employers as "integral and indispensable" or "principal"? E.g., could Amazon define the time spent walking from workspace-table to an equipment rack as outside the scope of paid work?
IANAL; I'm sure these questions have already been analyzed to death. If anyone knows where a layperson-accessible discussion is available I'd be grateful for a link.
[EDIT: reworded for clarity]
If I were in a hypothetical situation where I was an hourly worker and I had to spend 15 minutes at the beginning and end of the day setting up and tearing down my workspace, I would certainly expect that I would be paid for that time. But it's not clear that would be mandatory. (But maybe because I'd be on the premises?)
As you say, I'm sure these nuances have been analyzed to death and it does seem as if the courts have consistently taken a line that activities outside of the principal activities themselves (e.g. helping customers), even if required, mostly don't need to be compensated.
as a side note, let's not separate ourselves from lawyers in our ability to reason about and determine what's fair, ethical, and just. it's well within our power to interpret and rationalize about human relations.
a little specialized training in argumentation doesn't give lawyers special powers in this regard. that is, let's not fall for either regulatory capture or an appeal to authority (that's not to say that lawyers don't often have relevant specialized experience to bring to bear in litigation and negotiation).
It should be noted, though, that appellate court opinions usually contain many citations to prior cases, quoting excepts from those cases and applying much subtle reasoning to try to justify saying the present case is like the prior cases whose ruling are similar to the present court's ruling, and much subtle reasoning to try to distinguish the present case from those prior cases that came to a difference conclusion.
It's real easy to go off track when trying to follow this. When reading cases in law school I had to resort to using something like 6 different colors of highlighter at once to mark up the cases in my book to help keep track of what was going on.
Yes, we indeed can (mostly) all reason about and determine what is fair, ethical, and just. But we usually don't have to provide extensive justification for how we reached our conclusions, and most situations where we have to make such determinations are fairly straightforward.
Courts are usually dealing with edge cases, where there are conflicting interests and it is not possible to come to a fair, ethical, or just outcome for everybody.
and certainly we can't be fair, ethical, and just for everyone all the time, but i don't think that means we should cede legal authority to only a special class because the arguments can get subtle and intricate. if anything, it seems to be good rationale to me for putting more effort into making the law simpler and less opaque (realizing that's harder than it sounds).
This is the problem. The Supreme Court has no choice but to follow the law. It's up to Congress to change the law. This appears to be an outdated, badly written law that doesn't account for present circumstances.
Right vs. Left...conservative vs. liberal...doesn't matter if the laws were written correctly to begin with.
Imagine the debate over rewriting the 2nd Amendment to be clearer. ;-)
Enough people were outraged that it should not have been hard to get something done...but still nothing. Better to place blame on Trump than to make sure a permanent law could be passed.
Oh...and we shouldn't be leaving it up to the courts...by the time its at SCOTUS the damage has been done and everyone's time is wasted.
https://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/10/business/supreme-court-ru...
How is this case different from the precedent established by the Amazon case?
Edit:
In the 2014 case, it was the 9th Circuit that was being overruled. I wonder if this decision is destined for the same fate.