Re:Khan videos, learning, and reinforced misconceptions
by mcdaid on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:08AM
(#2436465)
This reminds me of my old chemistry teacher, we used to enjoy watching his demonstrations because half the time they didn't work. Excuses would be made about a bit dirt must have been in the test tube or out of date chemicals etc.
But it made the lesson interesting (we wanted to see it fail), watching a well made video is less engaging than seeing a live demonstration.
Re:Khan videos, learning, and reinforced misconceptions
by unknownguy on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @08:03AM
(#2436781)
Am I the only one thinking that having a good presentation alone is not enough to learn automatically? You need to practice what you learn to make it sink in.
In other words: it depends on the individual student to practice. Just looking at the teaching method and ignoring that factor is not enough imho.
EDIT to clarify: Criticizing something but ignoring a potentially big factor is not enough.
Re:Khan videos, learning, and reinforced misconceptions
by JoachimSchipper on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @05:36AM
(#2436501)
Interesting, but it doesn't seem to control for the possibility that study materials presented in a subtly different way are recalled better. (I'd imagine Arial is used a lot in schools...)
But it made the lesson interesting (we wanted to see it fail), watching a well made video is less engaging than seeing a live demonstration.
In other words: it depends on the individual student to practice. Just looking at the teaching method and ignoring that factor is not enough imho.
EDIT to clarify: Criticizing something but ignoring a potentially big factor is not enough.
http://bps-research-digest.blogspot.com/2010/12/harder-to-re...