News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by lend000 on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @04:26PM (#24357726)
Not too interesting for those interested in high performance desktop and server offerings. The fact that Intel's only new releases on 10nm are <=6 core low power products suggests their yields are still poor.

AMD did a really smart thing with their processor designs. Instead of doing a large monolithic multiprocessor like Intel (which may be able to eek out some extra performance due to optimized wire placements), they use smaller chiplets. This results in requiring no manufacturing errors on a much smaller area of the die (which becomes exponentially less probable as the area increases). Even if AMD was using Intel's 10nm process, their yields would be better because of their modular designs that get soldered together after the lithography. Intel can still bin out some errors (the 10300-10900k are all the same chip with different parts turned off due to manufacturing errors), but the less modular design likely makes this less efficient.

That's my understanding, anyway -- correct me if I'm wrong.

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by kllrnohj on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @05:29PM (#24358381)
> That's my understanding, anyway -- correct me if I'm wrong.

Since these are mobile processors your understanding is incorrect. What you've described is what AMD did on the server & desktop side. But on mobile, to hit the power efficiency targets, AMD stuck with the single monolithic die. And it's a decently large one, at that: https://www.anandtech.com/show/15381/amd-ryzen-mobile-4000-m...

So no AMD wouldn't yield better on Intel's 10NM+, not in this case. In the desktop usage they would, as their desktop CPU dies are way smaller than their mobile CPU dies. But the mobile die sizes are fairly equivalent between AMD & Intel.

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by celrod on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @11:06PM (#24360481)
If I understood lend000 correctly:

> The fact that Intel's only new releases on 10nm are <=6 core low power products suggests their yields are still poor.

Their argument was that, had they followed AMD's approach, they would be able to produce desktop and server chips despite being yield-limited to "<= 6 core" per chiplet.

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by disillusioned on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @09:10PM (#24359950)
>(the 10300-10900k are all the same chip with different parts turned off due to manufacturing errors)

Wow. Is this a relatively new phenomenon, or something that's been the norm in processor mfg for a long time? I know that the Ks were usually just binned/higher tested chips so they'd unlock those and charge a premium for them, but the idea that they're disabling parts of the die and separating the chip offering that way is crazy to me. Are the parts being disabled redundant or are they reducing the instruction set space? I don't know anything about how any of that would work.

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by cercatrova on Thursday September 03, 2020 @01:40AM (#24361070)
This price differentiation actually occurs in all products and companies. Look at SaaS, it's all the same software product but features are selectively enabled for higher-paying customers.

Something that's different between software and hardware such as chips are that the chips that have things disabled are done so because those disabled parts actually don't work. If you only yield 2 out of 4 cores, it's easier to just make it a dual-core CPU rather than throw the chip away.

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by dr_zoidberg on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @10:15PM (#24360263)
I remember hearing 10 years ago that Phenom x3 was a 4 core part that always got a dead core in manufacturing (:

So no, nothing new under the sun.

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by leovailati on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @11:03PM (#24360452)
I remember hearing something about the Cell processors on Playstation 3's being the ones with manufacturing errors. The 100% good ones were supposedly sold to the US military. I realize that second part was probably just a myth. Who knows, maybe it was all an internet myth! The PS3 was released in 2006, so the idea itself is not new.
Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by tikkabhuna on Thursday September 03, 2020 @02:33AM (#24361336)
A few years ago we had fun with the AMD HD 6950 graphics card. From what I remember, it was more popular than the higher specced 6970, so they simply detuned 6970s by deactivating shaders. Tools were then published by enthusiasts to enable those shaders and some manufacturers even added features to help you do it (mine had a little switch to reset the firmware if you screwed it up).

https://www.zdnet.com/article/upgrade-your-radeon-hd-6950-to...

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by srtjstjsj on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @11:30PM (#24360569)
The disabled parts are the broken parts.
Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by jagannathtech on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @11:07PM (#24360486)
insert the ohio astronauts meme

wait, it's all just binning?

it always has been.

;)

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by Voliokis on Thursday September 03, 2020 @01:17AM (#24360982)
It's been done for as long as I can remember.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_binning

Iirc, early Celeron were often just Pentiums with defective (and disabled) cache

Edit: https://www.anandtech.com/show/568/2

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by ajross on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @04:40PM (#24357871)
> The fact that Intel's only new releases on 10nm are <=6 core low power products suggests their yields are still poor.

That logic seems backwards. If you have poor yields you tend to favor higher-margin products (i.e. datacenter CPUs). This is a laptop CPU intended to sell at significantly lower $/mm2.

As far as chiplets: multichip packages are an ancient idea, and the industry goes back and forth on them. Both Intel and AMD shippsed multi-chip solutions way back in the day, the current age of integration is actually the anomaly. You win on yield but lose on package costs, and the decision as to which to use depends on the specifics of the market you're trying to target.

Certainly AMD would prefer to ship single-chip solutions and pocket the savings, but they can't. Likewise Intel accepts some loss of scaling because of the need to share die designs across the product line.

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by ustolemyname on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @04:50PM (#24357990)
The issue is your defect rate for larger chips. If a small laptop CPU only has 25% of chips being fully functional, a 4x the size server chip will only yield 0.39% of chips being defect free.

I say this having no idea what Intel's defect rate is right now, and I acknowledge fusing of bad sections can mitigate this a bit.

Re:Intel Launches 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake by aryonoco on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @10:34PM (#24360339)
Laptops (and for that matter mobile SoCs) are smaller, so higher defect rates can be tolerated as you can still get reasonable yields. you need a mature process to manufacture large chips (economically).