News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by jchrisa on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:13PM (#24345718)
In support of the requirement for high-fidelity (atom-for-atom) modeling is the notion that an evolved computer would converge toward behaviors that supervene on specifics of the host environment. If porting a binary to another CPU architecture is tough, how easy will it be to port a mind to a simulated simple physics? How many edge cases will it have to get right to even run at all? If brains are hacks designed over millions of generations to surf overlapping fitness functions, it makes sense they'd find implementation (real physics) dependent optimizations that compound in ways which fall apart in toy physics. That's not to say we can't add cool peripherals.

ps even with atom-for-atom modeling, how do you know the behavior doesn't depend on relations which are not computable? If physics ranges over the reals, some of those edge cases might be hard to find with a simulator.

Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by cylon13 on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:42PM (#24346107)
I can hit myself in the head and I don't lose my train of thought, instantly lose consciousness, or die. If consciousness relied on the precise positions of individual atoms (as far as that makes sense with moving particles) it would be way more fragile than we've observed it to be. The fact that your brain is resilient to being knocked around a bit is evidence towards the underlying mind being at least slightly higher level than where strong quantum effects live and also fairly redundant.
Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by im3w1l on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @05:32PM (#24347337)
I agree, but I think there is a case to be made that there is important state separate from just which cells connect to which and how strongly, but is also more coarse grained than single atoms floating around.

The cytoskeleton may be found out to have a role to play. The number and locations of ion pumps. Or epigenetic changes in clusters of brain cells.

Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by Franciscouzo on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @08:27PM (#24348739)
If you hit your head hard enough all those things will happen though.
Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by FeepingCreature on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:26PM (#24346629)
On the other hand, the brain is famously warm and wet. There's a limit to how much local state the brain can practically use to compute, given how messy it is.
Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by jjaredsimpson on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:37PM (#24346771)
>If physics ranges over the reals

I thought this was ruled out by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bekenstein_bound

Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by gnramires on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @09:10PM (#24359951)
That's my understanding as well. Quantum states encode finite information (despite their dynamics lying on the reals; the practical consequence is just that state transitions and information flow are smooth).

The formal discussion around this is largely centered on the Church-Turing thesis:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church%E2%80%93Turing_thesis

Essentially stating (in a certain interpretation) that any physical process can be simulated by a Turing machine (with no mention of efficiency). This seems to be the case, although I'm not sure we have a convincing proof from quantum field theory yet (note that quantum process can be simulated in classical Turing machines, although with an exponential cost).

Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by dsiroker on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @03:31PM (#24345967)
> If porting a binary to another CPU architecture is tough, how easy will it be to port a mind to a simulated simple physics?

It will be very difficult, but we shouldn’t underestimate what is possible decades from now. As an analogy, consider when the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) came out in the 1980s. Did anyone ever imagine it could be fully emulated in JavaScript in a browser [1]? Certainly not since those technologies hadn’t been invented yet.

[1] https://jsnes.org/

Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by indrax on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @04:42PM (#24346835)
What's JavaScript? What's a browser?
Re:Mind Emulation Foundation by GoblinSlayer on Wednesday September 02, 2020 @04:41AM (#24351228)
Hopefully the brain doesn't rely on undefined behavior.