News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by ootachi on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:31PM (#2433683)
But QuickTime doesn't work better for users. The technology is dated and does nothing that HTML5 doesn't do better. In fact, Flash is actually far better for consumers than QuickTime; at least it's updated regularly, unlike QT.

This cuts both ways. Why doesn't Apple discontinue and disable the QuickTime plugin, if they really have the users' interests at heart?

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by CountSessine on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:18PM (#2433943)
Actually, it's quite possible that much of what we think of as Quicktime will go away in OSX 10.7.

Apple has tried modernizing Quicktime with something called QTKit/Quicktime X. iOS did away with this altogether and instead uses something called AVFoundation. OSX 10.7 includes an OSX version of AVFoundation.

It's not 100% clear to me what the relationship between the two on OSX will be, but I'm guessing that Apple has given up on modernizing Quicktime and is just replacing it with AVFoundation.

This can't really come quickly enough. If Windows users are tired of Quicktime, well... it behaves a lot better on OSX if you're an end-user, but programming for Quicktime is a pain. In particular, programming codec plug-ins is horrible. The basic Quicktime architecture still deals with FSSpecs, memory handles, the old Component Manager, and API artifacts relating to the old code fragment manager from the pre-OSX days. Quicktime is probably the one big chunk of code in OSX that still dates from pre-OSX days and hasn't been re-implemented in terms of something more modern like Core Foundation.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by hamedh on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:57PM (#2434114)
What does HTML5 have anything to do with it? Many times you get linked straight to a movie file and the browser is expected to either play the file or download it (based on mime-types).

If they are disabling the Quicktime plugin on OS X, then at least just download the movie file even if the mime type is "video/quicktime".

The error screen they are showing now is scary enough that most people will abort out of it.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by cooldeal on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:48PM (#2433781)
And not to mention the annoying way the updater tries to sneak in Safari and other Apple software. http://i.imgur.com/oq0i2.png

It was far worse earlier http://www.dslreports.com/r0/download/1289538~04d191d10d05df...

Just as a thought exercise: Can't Apple be sued for monopoly abuse? They have a monopoly on portable music players, for which you need iTunes to load music on, and then they default to installing Safari trying to leverage their monopoly in music players to win over the browser market.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by dailyrorschach on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:18PM (#2433941)
I'm sorry, how do they have a monopoly on portable music players? They have a very popular player, of which they are the sole manufacturer, and require you to use their software.

The free market has plenty of alternatives, though not as good if you ask me, if you do not like their solution you are free to purchase another. There's nothing monopolistic about having a hugely successful product.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by metageek on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:43PM (#2434055)
I don't think "monopoly" requires 100% market share. Apple has over 75% market share, which may be enough to qualify.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by Wientje on Monday April 11, 2011 @04:04PM (#2434138)
You're allowed to have a monopoly, you're not allowed to abuse it. If Apple ordered mp3hardware stores to stop selling other brands or Apple would raise it prizes, that would be abuse.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by metageek on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @09:20AM (#2437035)
(a) The GP of my comment asserted that automatically installing Safari when you install iTunes was monopoly abuse. I think they at least have a point.

(b) Apple has about 2/3 of the paid music download market and 3/4 of the MP3 player market. They block other MP3 players from talking to iTunes, and other desktop software from talking to the iPod. I think that's probably abuse: they're using iTunes's dominant market position to protect the iPod's dominant market position, and vice versa.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by MatthewPhillips on Monday April 11, 2011 @04:09PM (#2434162)
Which is what Intel did to AMD.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by cooldeal on Monday April 11, 2011 @04:48PM (#2434288)
If that's the only metric, then why was Microsoft censured for bundling IE with Windows?
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by wtallis on Monday April 11, 2011 @09:17PM (#2435342)
They leveraged one monopoly to create another instead of trying to promote IE on its merits, and implemented IE with insider knowledge of how Windows works, and did various other things like coercing OEMs. Those are the things that got them in trouble, not simply having the OS monopoly.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by billmcneale on Monday April 11, 2011 @07:17PM (#2434910)
That's technically not the reason why they were "censured", although what you describe was seen as part of abusing their monopoly.

Like the commenter above said, there is nothing illegal with being a monopoly.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by Tycho on Monday April 11, 2011 @04:39PM (#2434254)
Portable music players isn't such a meaningful category when you consider most mobile phones can also play music; plus just other music listening devices in general.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by recoiledsnake on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:44PM (#2434060)
>There's nothing monopolistic about having a hugely successful product.

What is a monopoly then?

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by dailyrorschach on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:56PM (#2434113)
It may vary from nation to nation, but under US law the relevant act here is the Sherman Antitrust Act, which deals with single-firm anti-competitive behavior.

We'd have to wade through a lot of case-law here, but if you'll permit me the ability to speak without excessive sourcing (most of this can be found supported and sourced on Wiki)...

The courts have made a distinction between an innocent and a coercive monopoly. Where innocent monopolies, as you may argue but I disagree, are what Apple has in the music player space. These are not illegal. It would need to be shown that Apple has conspired in some way to grow and maintain their market position in a way to be detrimental to consumers and other producers.

Now on to whether it is a monopoly or not. This page can be helpful: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly#Monopoly_versus_compet...

Right now another consumer electronics company could: a) produce a new unit with a high quality software, b) sell it at a competitive price point to Apple, c) create a product very similar to the iPod itself, d) there already exist many other competitors. To me these factors suggest Apple does not have a monopoly but a very successful product.

And I'd submit as noted above, even if you found Apple to have a monopoly, I do not believe it would qualify as coercive under US law.

As noted in this thread, market share is not so much the issue, as barrier to entry.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by MatthewPhillips on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:50PM (#2434092)
(note: I have no opinion on whether iPod is or isn't a monopoly)

A monopoly requires that a company uses it's position of dominance to put up barriers to entry for competition.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by yuhong on Monday April 11, 2011 @08:23PM (#2435141)
I checked Apple Software Update on this computer and they are all unchecked by default.