News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by bogomips on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:03PM (#2433535)
No silly holy wars or sanctimonious proclamations.

I'm really torn trying to figure out which parts of your post is sarcasm. Because if you're really claiming that Apple hasn't pursued almost every initiative with "sanctimonious proclamations", you must not be paying attention. Gruber echos the Apple talk points, and they all revolve around "just trying to do right by the customer" (instead of "just trying to ensure massive profit margins aided by complete control and industry domination).

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by danilocampos on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:04PM (#2433541)
You suggest a dichotomy that doesn't exist.

Apple makes massive profit margins by doing right by the customer (as they see it).

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by bogomips on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:10PM (#2433569)
Apple makes massive profit margins by doing right by the customer (as they see it).

Sure, and so does Microsoft. That argument works for any company.

The problem is that many of Apple's transparent positions aren't held on their merit, but instead are shrouded behind layers of sanctimonious bullshit. See the anti-Flash screeds as an example of this. That you would claim that insult about Google, in this case, is quite laughable.

Though I see that HN is once again a bastion of pro-Apple delusion as the more enlightened fled.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by danilocampos on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:17PM (#2433600)
> Sure, and so does Microsoft. That argument works for any company.

I wish I could agree with you. In fact, for many companies, the customer is the last consideration. Especially in the case you've brought up here. Microsoft's financial might in the 90's was all about strategic relationships, three dimensional chess and out-maneuvering their competition through ethically dubious tactics, definitely not creating value for users.

"Primarily in the 1990s, critics contend Microsoft used monopolistic business practices and anti-competitive strategies including refusal to deal and tying, put unreasonable restrictions in the use of its software, and used misrepresentative marketing tactics; both the U.S. Department of Justice and European Commission found the company in violation of antitrust laws"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by kenjackson on Monday April 11, 2011 @04:03PM (#2434135)
But MS would argue, as Apple does, that they did this in the interest of the customer. Frankly, some of the things they were accused of, such as bundling IE, were absurd. Sure MS should have been more open about the fact that it really wasn't necessary, but bundling a browser is a requirement for a modern OS -- even as of 1998.

In any case, these are all religious as this point, and me proving your God is wrong is something one can't easily win.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by bogomips on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:21PM (#2433620)
Especially in the case you've brought up here. Microsoft's financial might in the 90's was all about strategic relationships, three dimensional chess and out-maneuvering their competition, definitely not creating value for users.

Microsoft and Apple both engage in identical behaviors. Many Microsoft boosters used the identical "for the consumer" arguments in defending Microsoft activities. Forcing IE while prohibiting competitive browser installations, for instance, simplified and created a cleaner, more user-accessible platform that would just work, blah blah blah. Same sort of nonsense you hear today.

That you would link to the anti-trust decree is bizarre. Do you think I or anyone else don't know about that? Do you think Apple's actions are so different, or is Apple simply not in control as much market as Microsoft (yet). Then again, they've already drawn anti-trust attention, so ten years from now some booster of the then-big-dog will point back at the DOJ-vs-Apple lawsuit as proof of....something.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by danilocampos on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:23PM (#2433636)
> Do you think I or anyone else don't know about that?

Kinda.

> Many Microsoft boosters used the identical "for the consumer" arguments in defending Microsoft activities.

I think the big difference here is that Apple is actually right. Flash on mobile is terrible for battery life and its implementations, so far, are shoddy.

There's a big difference on imposing your will over 25% of the market of rich people with fancy phones versus 96% of the market of everyone who needed a computer to get anything useful done. Apple has nowhere near the power Microsoft did.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by kenjackson on Monday April 11, 2011 @04:04PM (#2434142)
Flash on mobile is terrible for battery life and its implementations, so far, are shoddy.

Silverlight on mobile though has been pretty excellent. Curious if Apple would allow Silverlight on their platform? Probably not.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by Terretta on Monday April 11, 2011 @11:57PM (#2435813)
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by cooldeal on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:33PM (#2433695)
>I think the big difference here is that Apple is actually right. Flash on mobile is terrible for battery life and its implementations, so far, are shoddy.

What about HTML5 and Apple's promises? It's been a while since Jobs wrote that and still Apple's HTML5 implementation is not up to par. http://blog.millermedeiros.com/2011/01/ipad-is-the-new-ie6/

On top of that, Apple is in no hurry to bring the speed improvements of their Nitro JS engine to apps pinned to the homescreen. After all, they prefer devs to make native apps so that there is a lockin.

>There's a big difference on imposing your will over 25% of the market versus 96% of the market. Apple has nowhere near the power Microsoft did

What about tablets where Apple is deemed to have 94% of the market?

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by danilocampos on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:44PM (#2433759)
> On top of that, Apple is in no hurry to bring the speed improvements of their Nitro JS engine to apps pinned to the homescreen. After all, they prefer devs to make native apps so that there is a lockin.

I think minds smarter than I have put this particular notion to bed.

> Apple can't turn on the ability to do executable, dynamically written to memory pages just for their library: they'd have to turn it on for the entire process, at which point you could also do crazy things like download native code and execute it, bypassing the entire concept of their "codesign" mechanism.

Says saurik, of Cydia fame, in that and other comments. It's a security concern for Apple, not necessarily a strategic one.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2338338

Apple controls the tablet market only because they invented it as it currently exists a year ago. That's not really a useful comparison to the 90's, as desktop computers as a category had existed for a couple of decades. Moreover, tablets aren't currently essential to doing work, so the true power Apple has over others is negligible.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by cooldeal on Monday April 11, 2011 @03:12PM (#2433905)
>It's a security concern for Apple, not necessarily a strategic one.

You want me to believe that the engineering might of Apple haven't figured out the security for apps to make use of the new JS engine without getting full privileges? I think it's just not a priority for Apple.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by bigfudge on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:22PM (#2433626)
In addition to the comments re: Microsoft below, it's also worth remembering that for google you are the product (clicks) as well as the customer. Their loyalties are thus divided, and hence the shilly-shallying around with sort of but not quite banning link farms.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by bogomips on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:24PM (#2433641)
it's also worth remembering that for google you are the product (clicks) as well as the customer.

There aren't many exceptions to this. It is certainly true of Apple, where you are a consumer of their platform, and a conduit of their payment system, as much as you're a consumer of a specific product.

There's a reason Apple locks down their platform, and it isn't because they're looking out for your financial or competitive choice interests.

That you bought an iPhone is simply the first step, and that consumer-capture will be exploited for years. Apple wants to be your conduit of music and movies, applications, information and subscriptions, etc. They have no interest in selling you a device just to bid you adieu.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by tvon on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:49PM (#2433788)
> Though I see that HN is once again a bastion of pro-Apple delusion as the more enlightened fled.

It's good to know you can just fall back on calling people fanboys if you don't agree with their opinions.

Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by WiseWeasel on Tuesday April 12, 2011 @03:49PM (#2438883)
The difference is that Apple's customers are for the most part individual consumers, while Microsoft's are hardware OEMs and Google's are advertising partners. Thus, the interests of Apple's customers align much more with public interest than those of Microsoft or Google.
Re:Now Chrome disables Quicktime plugin by default by cooldeal on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:39PM (#2433728)
>Apple makes massive profit margins by doing right by the customer (as they see it).

What's right for the consumer about the compulsory 30% cut of iOS subscriptions for things like Readability, Kindle and Netflix? The uniform 43% increase for ALL customers while lining Apple's pockets for contributing basically nothing (unlike apps where they atleast provide hosting).

Edit: I am sure Android is bad for Apple's customers, no wonder they don't want it to be seen. http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2373502,00.asp