News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ubuntu 20.04’s zsys adds ZFS snapshots to package management by hnlmorg on Monday August 31, 2020 @09:00AM (#24331000)
Please excuse the ignorant question, but what grounds would Oracle have to sue Canonical?

OpenZFS is still open source and available on FreeBSD (amongst others). The licence might not be GPL compatible but the way ZFS is shipped on Linux there isn't any GPL/CDDL mixed code bases (and it's not like there isn't already a long history of GPL-incompatible software licences with Linux kernel modules anyway).

Re:Ubuntu 20.04’s zsys adds ZFS snapshots to package management by jblwps on Monday August 31, 2020 @09:27AM (#24331222)
IIRC, The GPL incompatibility prohibits distribution of linked binaries. Since the CDDL-licensed ZFS kernel modules have to be linked against the kernel, those compiled modules can't be distributed.

Hence, Canonical (or anyone else trying to re-release under the CDDL) cannot distribute binaries of the kernel modules.

However, you are fully allowed to compile and link the two on your own. This is why the alternative to binary distribution is compiling yourself with the help of DKMS.

Re:Ubuntu 20.04’s zsys adds ZFS snapshots to package management by boomboomsubban on Monday August 31, 2020 @10:09AM (#24331590)
With the two licenses incompatibility, the GPL is the one that would be violated, not the CDDL. So any Linux contributor would have the right to sue, including Oracle who presumably have committed to Linux. However, Oracle owning ZFS gives them no extra grounds to sue over OpenZFS.
Re:Ubuntu 20.04’s zsys adds ZFS snapshots to package management by diffeomorphism on Monday August 31, 2020 @09:28AM (#24331236)
"The way it is shipped" differs by distro and the message by non-ubuntu distros is that the way ubuntu ships zfs seems legally risky to them. Ubuntu disagrees and they might be right (isle of man jurisdiction IIRC?), but their legal theory has not been tested and oracle has a reputation.
Re:Ubuntu 20.04’s zsys adds ZFS snapshots to package management by hnlmorg on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @08:27AM (#24341052)
Even so, it's not CDDL (OpenZFS) license which is being violated but GPL (Linux).
Re:Ubuntu 20.04’s zsys adds ZFS snapshots to package management by rleigh on Monday August 31, 2020 @06:58PM (#24336716)
The licensing incompatibility is not arising from the CDDL licence, but the GPL. You can combine the CDDL with pretty much anything.

As a result, it would be extraordinarily difficult for Oracle to sue since it would not be the CDDL licence terms which were infringed.

Re:Ubuntu 20.04’s zsys adds ZFS snapshots to package management by hnlmorg on Tuesday September 01, 2020 @08:22AM (#24341002)
This was my takeaway as well. Which is why I was puzzled by the comments about Oracle suing Canonical.

That said, boomboomsubban (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24331590) suggested Oracle could sue on the GPL side of things since they have committed code to Linux. It would be interesting if such a position is possible and I suspect that could open the door to all sorts of frivolousness cases (eg closed binaries shipped with Android).