News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple blocked Facebook's attempt to tell users about 30% ... by raverbashing on Saturday August 29, 2020 @01:38PM (#24317858)
It's just absurd that's any transaction

For the app? Sure. Hosting, vetoing, version control, etc. (Even if we forget that developers already have to pay $99 a year). I'm fine with that. I would be more than fine if that $99 got more expensive the more app downloads you had.

For just processing an IAP? With no volume discounts? It's ridiculous.

Sure, they don't want the "free app + unlocking IAP" but they could think this better.

Re:Apple blocked Facebook's attempt to tell users about 30% ... by dathinab on Saturday August 29, 2020 @01:53PM (#24318013)
It gets even more ridiculous if you consider that there are cases with price bindings (e.g. books) or small not very flexible margins (per song buying of music) and apple is them self competing in this area without this cuts.

Similar ridiculous is that they effective prevent apps which just provide the service for existing member without any payment/sign-up services in the apple app.

This is a active intrusion on the free marked undermining the fundamental concepts of it (choice and transparency). At least in my opinion.

Re:Apple blocked Facebook's attempt to tell users about 30% ... by vchak1 on Saturday August 29, 2020 @01:56PM (#24318048)
Even for the app - if its a cost argument, then allow others to compete on a cost basis. Of course, apple will not let you set up your own app store with the same guarantees that apple provides around privacy security etc. If its a discovery and cost of marketing argument than I dont understand the perpetuity of payments, you can pay a first time purchase fee but subscriptions afterwards should not have any fees tacked on.
Re:Apple blocked Facebook's attempt to tell users about 30% ... by richardwhiuk on Saturday August 29, 2020 @02:05PM (#24318119)
If they don't do IAPs, then the former charge will just be subverted by "Free App with one time IAP".

That's already the case for most games - the game is free but most of the stuff is hidden by IAPs

Re:Apple blocked Facebook's attempt to tell users about 30% ... by raverbashing on Saturday August 29, 2020 @02:29PM (#24318302)
But you could differentiate one-off IAPs from subscription IAPs and from "added value/purchase" IAPs