Re:A broken algorithm that affected American transportation
by emn13 on Saturday August 29, 2020 @04:30AM
(#24314628)
Fuel taxes don't cover pollution related costs; they certainly don't additionally also cover road costs and indirect costs to the neighborhood. Infrastructure is funded as an investment for similarly indirect gains.
Comparing physical construction and maintenance costs to fuel taxes is excluding 99% of the costs and benefits; it's misleading comparison.
No it isn't. The theory is used for the proposition that you can't satisfy the whole demand because adding capacity creates more demand. But that's plainly false. Even at a very low price there isn't unlimited demand, so there is an amount of capacity that can satisfy the demand.
Moreover, fuel taxes do actually pay for a large fraction of road costs, generally something like half. That means you get more demand than you would with a pro rata allocation, but that's what you want, because an even larger portion of the road cost is fixed cost, and charging more than incremental cost results in inefficient resource utilization. You paid for the road, it's not at full capacity and yet you're discouraging productive use of it.