Yeah, I wasn't complaining that conclusive evidence should have been included, more than, because of the lack of proof, a list of examples shouldn't be used to make the point at all.
It's a blog post, not a PhD thesis. If you read Rand's other stuff or watch his talks, you can find plenty of evidence.
What else is there though?
I've no idea, I have little/no experience with SEO. But someone showing a list of websites and saying "these did well with white hat SEO - see, it does work!" doesn't convince me to agree with either side of the argument.
Which brings me to my next point: the gradient between black and white hat SEO is very wide and gray. The perception of hat color is largely dependent on the perceiver's opinion of the content in question. That's why Calacanis swears up and down Mahalo is not spam, and why no one here buys it.