News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by lalaland1125 on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:38AM (#24302336)
The real issue with Bitcoin and the reason why it is different from other assets is that there is no actual source of value. A good way of thinking about this is trying to consider the values of various assets if the government was about the make it illegal to trade them.

A house for instance would still be valuable because you can live in it. Facebook stock would still be valuable because it represents ownership in a real company that generates profit.

Bitcoin however is useless if you can't trade it. There is literally no reason to own Bitcoin except to eventually sell it to someone else.

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by BiasRegularizer on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:48AM (#24302380)
I believe this applies to all currencies - they don't have intrinsic values. The values are derived from the market. Be it USD, BTC, EUR, or the Zimbabwean dollar. However, the purpose of currency exists as a vehicle for wealth transfer.

IMO the biggest problem with most cryptocurrencies is their deflationary nature. Limited supply means they behave more like assets than currency. As currency nobody would want to spend it as they gain value over time. As an asset it lacks intrinsic value, and therefore overall market cap will tank slowly.

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by ogogmad on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:51AM (#24302398)
> As currency nobody would want to spend it as they gain value over time

The problem with this argument is that you have to spend money. You have to spend it on food, lodging, entertainment, and so forth. Even if a currency is deflationary, people still have needs.

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by BiasRegularizer on Friday August 28, 2020 @04:00AM (#24302441)
Yes, but one would prefer spending money using an inflationary currency since holding on to it devalues over time. As long as inflationary currencies exist, people will prefer to spending those first before deflationary currencies.
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by ogogmad on Friday August 28, 2020 @04:04AM (#24302466)
Let's say you store all your wealth in a deflationary currency, for the obvious reason that it gains value over time. Then converting it to an inflationary currency would simply add overhead. So you would spend the deflationary currency.
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by ZephyrP on Friday August 28, 2020 @05:49AM (#24303100)
Your opening hypothetical leaves the impression that the words which follow it were either an alternate rehearsal for a more blunt observation: "if all your wealth is deflationary, to spend is to lose deflationary currency" or an earnest counterargument-by-analogy which contradicts something very near the bedrock of my own common sense about money; why would anyone with savings in a deflationary currency and the opportunity to spend inflationary currency decide to have & hold that which would decrease in value in favor of (equivalently denominated) spending which won't?
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by BiasRegularizer on Friday August 28, 2020 @07:31AM (#24303644)
I suggest you look into modern economic theories and why inflation is crucial to economic development. There are two problematic assumptions in your statement:

1. Nobody would store all their wealth in a deflationary currency - other forms of assets, stocks etc will still exist. They will need a high liquidity vehicle to trade a.k.a inflationary currency.

2. Deflationary currency doesn't necessarily mean it will gain value overtime. Unless it contains growing intrinsic value, the overall market cap will drop/plateau.

Think of inflation vs deflation as lubricant vs sandpaper, one encourages economic activities while the other discourages.

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by ljlolel on Sunday August 30, 2020 @02:23PM (#24324760)
1. bitcoin is high liquidity (even higher liquidity than currencies in that you can trivially transfer $1B), unlike all of the other assets like stocks and houses....

2. Exactly which is why people would be fine spending a "deflationary" currency

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by twelve40 on Friday August 28, 2020 @06:14AM (#24303235)
I believe this is completely wrong, the values of many important currencies are not at all derived from some vague market value, but are very actively centrally fought for, and controlled by the respective governments, and their respective economic and military might, and reserves - no equivalent in the typical cryptocurrency world. The decision to devalue the currency to save the economy, the decision to change course and peg a currency to something else entirely, the centralized fight to contain hyperinflation with all resources of a government, these have nothing to do with "deriving values from the market".

In contrast, there is no central government with military and reserves that can decide to manufacture an extra $3 trillion same price BTC on a whim to temporarily address a virus, or to devalue BTC to save the local economy, most crypto "currencies" just don't seem to work that way.

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by BiasRegularizer on Friday August 28, 2020 @07:47AM (#24303747)
You didn't quite get the point. As individual currencies governments exert a lot of power over their relative value to other currencies. As a whole, worlds fiat currencies hold no intrinsic value. No government can dictate that a kilogram of gold to only cost $1.
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by ogogmad on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:42AM (#24302355)
You could say the same thing about gold throughout much of history. The value of Bitcoin (and historically, gold) is in its stock-to-flow, its fungibility, its divisibility, and so forth. Its use case is mainly as a potential store-of-value, and perhaps even as a medium of exchange.
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by arcticbull on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:44AM (#24302362)
Yes, the big difference is gold, once extracted, doesn't cost 0.5% of the entire world's electricity supply to perform 7 transactions per second, which also generate 98g of e-waste each. You can perform a practically unlimited number of transactions per second with gold.

Either way, both aren't particularly useful as currency because rigid deflationary currency is bad. Deflation creates inequality, and preserves inequality over time. Rigid currencies are unable to respond to shocks. They are also unable to adapt to the addition of new market participants (births).

Give me one good reason why your dollars that you earned in exchange for goods and services should be worth more tomorrow than they are today?

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by bigiain on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:56AM (#24302422)
> You can perform a practically unlimited number of transactions per second with gold.

But but but - there's a hard upper limit!!! There's barely 3x10^19 atoms in 1 gram of gold! /s

(Obviously we could trade electrons, protons, and neutrons on a side chain to scale transactions up by almost 3 orders of magnitude...)

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by arcticbull on Friday August 28, 2020 @04:17AM (#24302541)
To be fair, we actually tried the side-chain model when the dollar was backed by gold :) the crypto folks are just speed-running the history of finance. I don't wanna spoil the surprise, but of course, it ended poorly.
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by bigiain on Friday August 28, 2020 @04:22AM (#24302561)
I guess there's a good analogy connecting "floating the dollar" and "stable coins" somewhere. "These crypto coins are 1:1 backed with US Dollars! Except when we arbitrarily decide they aren't any more! Watch the invisible hand at work!!!"
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by arcticbull on Friday August 28, 2020 @04:50AM (#24302740)
Or when international law enforcement decides they're not because 30% of the backing dollars are the proceeds of money laundering. Then you pretend it's fully backed anyways, raise an LEO just because, and move on because crypto. Ah, I do so love the future.
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by lalaland1125 on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:48AM (#24302378)
Gold has historically been a pretty bad investment over time compared to actual value generating assets: https://www.macrotrends.net/2608/gold-price-vs-stock-market-...
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by mac_was on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:46AM (#24302367)
I would not agree, gold is material, and wnehenver in the world you go with a piece of gold you can easily sell it, you don't need computer , electricity and in the case of Armageddon if you survive you will still be able to buy food using gold afterwards.
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by bigiain on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:59AM (#24302434)
Maybe. But you're gona need gasoline to trade with Bullet Farm...
Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by qes on Friday August 28, 2020 @04:31PM (#24309597)
What makes you think that after the Armageddon I'd be willing to trade my food for your gold.

Wtf am I going to do with a chunk of gold?

Re:Winklevoss 500k Bitcoin Argument by rakoo on Friday August 28, 2020 @03:42AM (#24302358)
Much the same can be said about gold. There are some uses, but it's definitely not the reason gold has the value it has today.