Re:Entrepreneurs Are Artists
by george_morgan on Sunday April 10, 2011 @10:44AM
(#2429542)
I think it’s partly to do with the (over) use of the phrase “x is an art,” usually meaning “x is a very skilled and hard thing to do successfully.” For example, it feels quite natural to say something such as “running a business is an art.”
Which is fine, but the natural corollary of x is an art is that whoever does x is an artist. Which leads to this confusion.
Isn't that just semantics? Is a master woodworker not an artist? I have seen some really beautiful furniture in are galleries (functional furniture too).
Don't the best craftsmen consider themselves artists?
Re:Entrepreneurs Are Artists
by jamesbritt on Sunday April 10, 2011 @06:45PM
(#2430638)
Isn't that just semantics? Is a master woodworker not an artist?
Do you mean a highly skilled crafts-person, i.e. an artisan? Or do you mean someone who creates experiences that challenge one's understanding and perception of themselves and their world?
I have seen some really beautiful furniture in are galleries (functional furniture too).
So have I, but I've yet to see any furniture that created an experience for me similar to to that of seeing certain works by van Gogh or Delacroix or Duchamp, or hearing works by Tchaikovsky or Reich.
Founders are (at least in some cases) craftsmen. That's the word that they're looking for. There are all sorts of craftsmen who are not "artists". It sounds cooler to style ourselves artists, but that doesn't make it true.
There's a spectrum between functional craft and pure art, but it's not entirely clear to me that startups are even on that spectrum and if they are, it's hard panned towards the functional side.