At the tail end there is only so much energy available and I am pessimistic that basic physics, like heat death of the universe, can be overcome.
However, we don’t even need to reach this tail end. Extreme events happen all the time and on a long enough time scale they become certainty. Maybe we can conquer aging but we are still physical bodies, which will forever be fragile (on the cosmic scale of supernovae and formation of compact objects, but really even on the scale of planetary calamities like sufficiently energetic asteroids or super volcanoes).
Heck, even if we spread everywhere in space, without ftl travel, which I am somewhat comfortable will never happen, we are stuck with the destiny of Milky Way, and that’s a very finite destiny.
hackernews: "here's some more reasons to fear death"
me: man chgrp
The fear of death was seriously bothering me and I thought: " You can either try to achieve immortality or try to loose your fear of death within your lifetime."
The second one is a solvable problem, the first one, for me personally, not. It gives a strange comfort that one day I might be free of the fear of death even if I know that still I will die.
Even if you were able to postpone your non-existence to some late stage of the Universe, it's all but assured you will have to end eventually in light of postulated Cosmological denouements. In other words, you will not exist forever due to physics.
That being said it would be nice to know it's possible to get at least a few hundred years of healthy and happy living in. Yet, would the fear of the end grow even greater then?
Anyway, this is going all scifi and silly. My point is really that death sucks, trying to say "oh but you can't fear death because it's not a thing" doesn't seem helpful, and we can probably do massively better than a ~125 year max lifespan.
Why is time not symmetrical? I don’t mean from your subjective point of view but in terms of objective physical reality. The answer is: entropy increases over time. Which is the same reason that death is inevitable. Perhaps one day people will live for ten thousand years and perhaps that would be nice, but death will still find us all eventually.
1. I think there's a big difference between 100 years and quadrillions of years.
2. I think that in quadrillions of years our interpretation of life and the value we derive from it, and our knowledge of the physical universe, may shift enough that "death" is not actually inevitable.
3. I'm no physicist but it seems a bit extreme to believe that we can predict quadrillions of years into the future based on an extremely limited view of the existing world and past. Is heat death inevitable? I don't know.
Maybe so. Or maybe this is a defense mechanism borne from denial and the urge to put off the inevitable. You’re talking about outliving the stars themselves when we can barely get piles of rocks to survive a few millennia.
> I think that in quadrillions of years our interpretation of life and the value we derive from it, and our knowledge of the physical universe, may shift enough that "death" is not actually inevitable.
But it was already thousands of years ago that our interpretation of life and the value we derive from it reached the understanding that death was not to be feared in the first place.
Sure, could be.
> You’re talking about outliving the stars themselves when we can barely get piles of rocks to survive a few millennia.
Maybe so. I won't pretend to understand what would go into such a thing. I don't personally believe our understanding of the universe is sufficient to rule it out.
> But it was already thousands of years ago that our interpretation of life and the value we derive from it reached the understanding that death was not to be feared in the first place.
I guess I missed that! I mostly see a lot of mental gymnastics or denial in the form of believe in an after-life.
I guess I don’t see the big distinction between some science-fiction fantasy of living for a quadrillion years and disproving the second law of thermodynamics and just believing in an afterlife. The alternative to either approach is discussed in OP :)
I see what you mean. What is it about death you fear? I think for these things, like starvation, loneliness, and dying, I don't fear them inherently, I fear their effects. I will feel physical pain while starving; I will feel emotional pain while lonely; I might feel pain while dying. But while living, I don't fear being dead because principally, I fear pain, and I won't be experiencing pain when I am dead. I understand not everyone will feel the same way about being dead, though.
> As the philosopher Thomas Nagel observed, death is the great deprivation.
That really resonates with me. Death deprives me of all things that I love and want.
The line has to be drawn somewhere, otherwise logically speaking we ought to force everyone into permanent suspended animation on life support machines. But clearly that would be a very bad thing to do.
If I said "we should cure the flu" would you say "Well sure but we can't just cure the flu by murdering everyone" ? Like yes, I guess there's a line there?
But we already are, in the sense that medical and safety research is constantly being conducted and there are professionals whose job is to rescue people from fires and similar disasters. There's always trade-offs though. A lot of death could be prevented by banning motor vehicles, should we do that? Of course not. In some ways, it could be argued that we're already going too far to prevent death, for example by banning doctor-assisted suicide.
> Your demise is inevitable. I hope that doesn’t come as too much of a shock.
There's a lot less work going into increasing our maximum lifespan that there is going into increasing our average lifespan.
> No doubt you don’t fear your prenatal existence and logically speaking, given their equivalence, it follows that you should fear death the exact same amount, as in not at all.
Prenatal existence is not symmetrical to death, in my opinion. First off, even if they were, neither can be conceived, which makes the symmetry unknowable. But more importantly I don't fear things that have happened, I fear things that are impending - a pretty key distinction here, which I feel fundamentally breaks the symmetry (ie: time is not symmetrical).
> doesn’t seem to be the sort of thing that one can reasonably be fearful of because it isn’t anything.
Earlier it was described as the greatest deprivation. Of course that's something. This is like saying "why fear starvation? It is only the absence of something - food". It is the absence, the nothingness, that drives that very fear.
This is like saying "Why fear loneliness? It is not something that is done to you, it is only the absence of love".
Perhaps death is 'nothing', whatever that means. Why is 'nothing' a special 'thing' that I can not fear? It seems just as reasonable to fear 'nothing' as anything else.
IDK, I don't find any of it compelling. Fix death please, that's a good way to prevent the fear.