News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by dhosek on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:37PM (#24284153)
Nobody seems to be talking about the sonic boom issue. People often assume that the sonic boom is a single event that happens when the plain exceeds the speed of sound, but rather its a continuous event that happens at supersonic speed which is why the Concord was used only for transatlantic service. A supersonic plane would not be practical for any overland route.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonic_boom

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by liability on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:57PM (#24284383)
The premise of Boom Technologies is that the intensity of the sonic boom can be managed by creating an aircraft with a sufficiently clever shape. I don't know exactly how that's meant to work, but it's this premise that they hope to demonstrate with the small-scale XB-1 in 2021.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by bernulli on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:40PM (#24284963)
The key thing is that the absolute pressure rise through the shock wave isn't very high - it's just perceived as a loud boom when it is reached in a very short time.

The pressure wave is ultimately caused by displacement because of the volume of the aircraft, lift, and engines. We cannot really get rid of any of these. Given enough time, a strong enough pressure pulse will steepen into the double-shock 'N-wave' (because the pressure signal is N-shaped) the sonic boom.

Sonic boom mitigation then means to prevent the pressure waves from steepening into a boom before it hits the ground, e.g. by a long nose, lift distribution over a large part of the aircraft length, putting the engines on top so that their pressure wave radiates upwards, etc.

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by Tossrock on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @06:20PM (#24287964)
Uninformed speculation: I wonder if you could mitigate via a precisely out-of-phase second boom which destructively interfered with the first one? Kind of like noise cancelling headphones. Schlieren photography shows us that there are actually multiple waves being produced over the body based on where the geometry experiences sharp changes, so maybe if those were designed juuust right?
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by bernulli on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @08:05PM (#24288749)
Unfortunately, it turns out that (for ideal gases, such as our atmosphere) a 'negative shock', i.e. a rarefaction shock, is impossible. It would violate the 2nd law of thermodynamics!

And if you have multiple, subsequent shocks (one at the aircraft tip, another at the engine inlet, another at the wing, etc), the later ones will eventually catch up to the first one, resulting in the N wave we would want to avoid.

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by andi999 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:18PM (#24284665)
Can one short sell a non listed startup?
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by liability on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:36PM (#24284921)
I don't think they're going to be a commercial success, but I don't really have a reason to doubt the possibility of new supersonic aircraft being quieter than older ones. Is there some particular reason to doubt this aspect of Boom's proposal?
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by andi999 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:09AM (#24290310)
The supersonic boom basically comess from the medium and nobody has been able to get rid of it. So the boom is not an engineering problem but a physics problem. Startups can solve engineering problems but rarely invent new physics (which might exist, mind you).

So this new product will be limited to the same routes as concorde (plus pacific if they manage extra long haul).

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by liability on Thursday August 27, 2020 @10:05AM (#24293825)
The supersonic boom comes from the interactions between the aircraft and the medium, not from the medium itself. I think it stands to reason that the properties of the boom can be manipulated by manipulating the properties of the aircraft's shape. It's not even controversial that some aircraft design elements can reduce the intensity of sonic booms, the only question is whether Boom has enough know-how to achieve the house levels they promise.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by renewiltord on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @04:24PM (#24286858)
Yes, but you need to do it manually and know someone willing to lend you the shares. There's no exchange I know of.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by bananabreakfast on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:22PM (#24284720)
Almost all of the research on sonic booms and their effect on residential noise levels was done in the 1950s.

Our knowledge of transonic aerodynamics and aircraft design have improved considerably sense then and much of the "common" knowledge that sonic booms will shatter windows and disrupt everyday life as a plane flies overhead at cruising altitude are very much outdated.

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by dhosek on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:43PM (#24286430)
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by rozab on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @05:27PM (#24287474)
Concorde wasn't that long ago. Londoners still remember.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by gsnedders on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:09PM (#24288331)
Concorde didn't fly over London at supersonic speeds, and I doubt it often flew over London a cruise altitudes.

The problem with Concorde on approach/departure was largely a function of its engines, rather than speed. https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/1973-07-18/debates/427... shows it was comparable to slightly older aircraft at the time of introduction (VC10, B707, DC8) but notably louder than what was arguably its biggest competitor (747-200). In later years, continued improvements in aircraft noise pollution meant the margin between Concorde and other aircraft operating out of LHR just grew larger and larger.

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by rbanffy on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:55PM (#24284359)
The Overture is smaller than the Concorde, so that a lower level of noise is expected. There has been some developments in aerodynamics for minimizing the shock by spreading it over a larger area, but, as you point out, they don't mention it.

It is probably part of their "secret sauce".

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by liability on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:04PM (#24284482)
Another difference between the proposed Overture and the Concorde is the engines. Concorde used turbojets with afterburners during takeoff, while Boom proposes a turbofan design without afterburners, which should in theory make it quieter for communities adjacent to airports. However the XB-1 small scale version will use turbojets according to Wikipedia.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by rbanffy on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:17PM (#24284638)
True, but I would imagine engine noise to be a relatively small part of the sonic boom issue.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by tomatocracy on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @02:34PM (#24285675)
I saw Concorde taking off a few times up close at air shows when it was still in service. It was significantly louder than any other aircraft I've ever been near (it had 4 enormous engines with afterburners - not that surprising I guess). Takeoff noise really was a big issue.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by soylentcola on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @04:54PM (#24287154)
It used to fly over my house when I was a teenager. I lived an hour or two (drive) from Dulles Airport and when it (rarely) passed overhead, it was still fairly loud. Nothing like you'd hear at an air show, but we always knew to look up if we heard it when we were out in the yard.

It was pretty cool because it was close enough to takeoff that you could easily make out the distinct shape of the plane.

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by gsnedders on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:12PM (#24288355)
Note the proposed Concorde B that never actually reached production due to cancelled orders of the A variant went without the afterburners.

I don't recall it being significantly louder than any other aircraft I've been near, but the vast majority of aircraft that were any where close were military aircraft!

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by liability on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:31PM (#24284845)
I think you're right, though take-off noise was also the subject of many complaints about the Concorde, not just the sonic boom. Reducing take-off noise was already one of the design considerations of the Concorde, and supposedly the Concorde was better in this regard than the Russian Concordeski (Tu-144.)
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by praveen9920 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @11:10AM (#24294435)
im not sure if they will be commercially successful but the technology sure seems like it is much more valuable than actually building a plane and run operations
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by tachyonbeam on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:45PM (#24284249)
Is it very loud even when planes are over 30,000 feet altitude? Can supersonic planes easily cruise at subsonic speeds when preparing to land?
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by dhosek on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:58PM (#24284395)
From the linked wikipedia article:

>In the late 1950s when supersonic transport (SST) designs were being actively pursued, it was thought that although the boom would be very large, the problems could be avoided by flying higher. This assumption was proven false when the North American XB-70 Valkyrie started flying, and it was found that the boom was a problem even at 70,000 feet (21,000 m). It was during these tests that the N-wave was first characterized.

Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by rbanffy on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:56PM (#24284372)
They do, but the wings have a lot of drag that the engines must compensate for.
Re:Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in... by warmcat on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @07:28PM (#24288484)
I am fine with an aircraft which takes me supersonic over Atlantic/Pacific and then switches to subsonic over land on my way to Asia.