News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by rayiner on Saturday April 09, 2011 @05:47PM (#2428171)
Groklaw filled a huge void. Done by someone who is a proponent of free software but also knowledgable about the law. As similar debates rage on in copyright and patent spaces, I think the need for that perspective will remain. We don't need more commentary from folks who don't know what the patent act §101 bars are. We need folks who understand the legal framework and can advocate for consumer rights within that framework. Hopefully someone steps in to fill PJ's shoes.
Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by grellas on Saturday April 09, 2011 @07:32PM (#2428386)
Groklaw has been a fantastic resource, reporting on important legal developments affecting IP with a depth, sagacity, and honesty that is not easily found elsewhere. I strongly second the idea that this leaves a huge void. It will take a lot to fill it.
Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by cooldeal on Saturday April 09, 2011 @10:06PM (#2428622)
I know the following sentiment will not be popular here, but here I go anyway(bye bye karma).

I really liked Groklaw in the SCO days but after that it seems to have degenerated into a place for Microsoft haters. I do not know if her investigations led her to seeing a Microsoft shadow everywhere but it felt like too much of a witch hunt to me, along with related sites like boycottnovell.com (now techrights.org). And Apple almost always gets a free pass even if they attack 'open'. Even her last post is a microcosm of this.

>But the world has moved from computers and desktops to mobile and the cloud. Now it's Microsoft and all its venal little helpers and proxies attacking Google and Android....No matter what tricks Microsoft may pull going forward, the world knows now that when there was free choice in the marketplace, people chose Android, which runs on Linux, over Microsoft's phone. Nothing they do can change that. All they can prove perhaps is that dirty tricks and misuse of the courts and regulatory bodies can distort the marketplace. But without the benefits of a monopoly, people don't actually choose Microsoft phones, at least not in comparison to Android. All they can do about that now is try to force you to use their products.That's in a way what a monopoly is.

People did not choose Android because it was open or because it was Linux. They choose it because the devices had multitouch capacitative screens(same as the iPhone) and ran on non AT&T carriers while Windows Mobile devices had resistive screens forcing use of a stylus and were not touch friendly, didn't have proper GPUs, suffered fragmentation etc. Windows Phone 7 is a total ditching of the old paradigm and a fresh start, but it came quite late and is facing an uphill battle against the network effects(yes, the same network effects that a monopoly or duopoly entail). If it was around when Android started, it could've been a very different market now, regardless of PJ's ramblings about monopolies. The new Windows phones are actually not bad compared to Androi but are missing many features. How can she declare victory for Android when WP7 has been barely out 5 months yet?

Interesting to see that she sweeps under the carpet things like Apple filing patent lawsuits against Android phones, and Jobs insinuating that Android is for porn. I sometimes feel that she plays to her primarily anti-MS audience, especially to keep things interesting to them after the SCO case ran out of gas but at the same time cannot criticize Apple too much even if deserved since that would anger the pro-Apple portion of the crowd.

In short, while the legal analysis was great, the bias, witch hunts and paranoia got too overwhelming once the SCO case stopped being interesting and it was the time that I stopped reading it regularly and I've seen some people who share this sentiment so I am not alone on this. Microsoft is definitely not an angel, but to obessively see it as a devil behind everything is a bit too much.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by wtallis on Saturday April 09, 2011 @10:54PM (#2428682)
I think the conspiracy theories, etc. were certainly bothersome, but they were far from overwhelming. It's important to keep in mind that basically nobody is in the business of following and publicly reporting on Microsoft's money trail, so in recent years we've only had weak evidence for their ties to SCO and their influence over the ISO standardization of OOXML. The myriad other possibilities probably were never investigated enough to have a chance of leaving the crackpot realm. We're left with only shreds of evidence, like certain lawyers being shared by everybody trying to undermine the GPL with a lawsuit, and Novell's IP being bought by a consortium that Microsoft put together.

To me, the greatest immediate loss is her reporting on Sony's legal activities. Even Ars Technica has not gone to the level of depth that PJ's analysis has, and I don't think anybody else has been diligent about tracking what Sony says in prosecuting Hotz vs. defending against the class action. There have also been several occasions where PJ has been the one to dampen sensationalism by not taking the legal filings at face value (eg. the accusations that Hotz had fled the country, or that Sony had a smoking-gun match for his serial number and IP address).

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by contextfree on Saturday April 09, 2011 @10:49PM (#2428676)
I agree completely, but think you should've done without the "disclaimer" at the beginning - that always comes off as whiny (or egotistical - a martyrdom complex).
Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by 3dFlatLander on Monday April 11, 2011 @01:44AM (#2431549)
> I know the following sentiment will not be popular here, but here I go anyway(bye bye karma).

Eesh.. please don't do that. It's not really 'baiting people to downvote you' per the comment guidelines, but baiting the contrarians to upvote you.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by FlorianMueller on Sunday April 10, 2011 @12:32AM (#2428788)
During all those years Groklie never once criticized IBM for any of its wrongdoings. In connection with IBM's software patent threat letter to TurboHercules, Groklie even said in a headline that IBM was "free to sue the pants off TurboHercules". Seriously, which free software advocate would ever cheer a patent aggressor on?
Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by wtallis on Sunday April 10, 2011 @01:42AM (#2428937)
In the article you refer to[1], it is shown that IBM was not the aggressor, as TurboHercules filed the first complaint, and the "threat letter" was merely IBM calling their bluff: "Your suggestion that TurboHercules was unaware that IBM has intellectual property rights in this area is surprising." Furthermore, the letter was a response to a request that IBM identify any intellectual property TurboHercules infringed.

Your refusal to take those facts into account is far more damning than PJ's belief that IBM's patent pledge did not cover TurboHercules.

[1][http://www.groklaw.net/articlebasic.php?story=20100408153953...]

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by FlorianMueller on Sunday April 10, 2011 @03:02AM (#2429063)
You are wrong about IBM not having been the aggressor. Here's a documentation of the entire correspondence: http://fosspatents.blogspot.com/2010/04/turbohercules-entire...

TurboHercules didn't make a "request" to IBM as a "bluff". Instead, IBM threatened TurboHercules with a previous letter.

Also, TurboHercules never attacked IBM with patents (I guess TurboHercules doesn't even own any patents). All that TurboHercules did later was to lodge an antitrust complaint with the European Commission. However, lodging a complaint with a regulator is not an act of aggression. Regulatory agencies will only take action if a company's conduct is suspected of being anticompetitive and unlawful. The European Commission launched an investigation in July: http://fosspatents.blogspot.com/2010/07/european-commission-...

That would not have happened if there weren't serious concerns over what IBM is doing. The outcome of the in-depth investigation remains to be seen, but the European Commission doesn't launch such investigations unless there's at least a strong indication of possible wrongdoing.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by nl on Sunday April 10, 2011 @09:03AM (#2429410)
lodging a complaint with a regulator is not an act of aggression. Regulatory agencies will only take action if a company's conduct is suspected of being anticompetitive and unlawful.

Wow.. that's an interesting spin.

The cynic in me wants to say "lodging a lawsuit is not an act of aggression. Courts will only take action if a company's conduct is proved to be unlawful."

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by FlorianMueller on Sunday April 10, 2011 @09:24AM (#2429431)
Contrary to my statement being "an interesting spin", your statement displays a total lack of understanding for antitrust law and patent law.

Worse than that, you don't even seem to understand that antitrust regulators aren't courts of law.

If you sue someone over patent infringement allegations, and as long as you satisfy some basic criteria (such as "Rule 11"), there will be a lawsuit. It's a given that the court will hear your case. Period. And it's only because you as the patent holder want to assert your rights, regardless of whether that particular case is good or bad for the economy at large, and for society.

By contrast, an antitrust complaint like the one TurboHercules brought against IBM (many months after the initial - even if then not yet totally specific - patent infringement threat) is lodged with a regulatory agency that doesn't have an obligation to follow up. They can always say there's no public interest in what you complain about. In that case, you could try to bring an antitrust lawsuit, and then you just satisfy some basic criteria and a court will hear the case. But if you ask an antitrust regulator to act, the regulatory agency will look at your complaint and its merits, and will compare it to other complaints and their merits, and will then decide to pursue only the most important issues, i.e., the ones that the economy at large, and society, have the greatest benefit from.

Depending on the jurisdiction, the antitrust regulator will either have to go to court at some point (unless a case is settled before) or, such as in the EU's case, the regulator may be in a position to impose remedies and fines, but all of that will be subject to review by a court of law if the affected company appeals.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by nl on Sunday April 10, 2011 @11:19PM (#2431238)
I understand perfectly well.

Complaining to an antitrust regulator is analogous to making a police complaint. The police may or may not do anything, in which case you can always file a civil lawsuit.

Trying to present making a complaint as some kind of innocent move is misleading at best.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by wtallis on Sunday April 10, 2011 @12:58PM (#2429841)
Is there any way for IBM to notify someone of potential infringement that you wouldn't call a threat?
Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by FlorianMueller on Sunday April 10, 2011 @01:19PM (#2429886)
There can be different objectives of informing someone of potential infringement:

1) making someone aware but saying right away that it's fine (that's what IBM as a self-declared friend and protector of open source should have done in this context)

2) making someone aware and offering a license deal on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms; that would have made sense in this case, too, since TurboHercules stated in its first letter that it wanted to reach an agreement with IBM on such terms

3) making someone aware while simultaneously pursuing exclusionary, anticompetitive objectives

I like the first possibility, I can accept the second one if the offered terms are truly FRAND, but I despise the third option.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by wtallis on Sunday April 10, 2011 @02:12PM (#2430002)
How about option

4) making someone aware and giving them the opportunity to cease and desist from commercial infringing activity

Is that a threat?

It's one thing to tolerate infringement from a community open-source project. It's another thing to let someone commercialize that technology and bundle it with hardware when a fully proprietary competitor would reasonably expect to be sued in to bankruptcy in no time flat. Should the fact that part of your business is "open" give the whole business immunity from patent infringement claims?

Also, IBM isn't "a self-declared friend and protector of open source". They only made a limited non-aggression pledge. They aren't (and aren't trying to be) in the same category as the FSF and EFF, or even RedHat.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by FlorianMueller on Sunday April 10, 2011 @02:25PM (#2430033)
Your point 4 is just a different way to phrase my point 3, the worst option of all.

Similarly, your distinction between a "community open-source project" and someone bundling it with hardware makes no sense. Companies bundling open source software with hardware or commercializing it in other ways are simply part of the community as long as they comply with open source terms.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by wtallis on Sunday April 10, 2011 @02:55PM (#2430109)
So any use of software patents is unduly "exclusionary [and] anticompetitive", especially when applied to commercial users of open-source software?

I hadn't really picked up a strong "they're all wrong" vibe from what I've seen of your coverage of the smartphone mess.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by FlorianMueller on Sunday April 10, 2011 @03:08PM (#2430138)
You're now trying, not for the first time in this discussion, quite desperately to pretend not to understand what I say.

You previously just phrased my 3rd option differently to artifically create a 4th option.

Now you don't take into account that I explained 3 different approaches: grant a free license, grant a FRAND license, and prohibit any implementation of the patented invention only to foreclose competition, which is exactly what IBM (a monopolist in the context we're discussing) tried. Fortunately, the European Commission is investigating IBM for suspected violations of EU competition law.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by wtallis on Sunday April 10, 2011 @03:28PM (#2430193)
You're implying that any use of patents to stifle competition is probably illegal, and should certainly be investigated. That rather thoroughly contradicts the definition of "patent".

Further, IBM's decade of tolerating Hercules development suggests that they do see a difference between community infringement and commercial infringement.

Re:Bittersweet news from Groklaw: mission accomplished, sign... by FlorianMueller on Monday April 11, 2011 @12:12AM (#2431349)
Your first paragraph is, once again, a complete strawman as opposed to what I said or implied. Not granting a license to a patent on FRAND terms is certainly anticompetitive, but not necessarily illegal. If, however, a monopolist does so in order to foreclose competition, then it raises serious antitrust issues and can, as the result of a regulatory process or lawsuit, be deemed illegal.

Your second paragraph doesn't make sense to me given that the patents asserted by IBM in that correspondence were related to the Hercules open source emulator, not specific to any commercial offering. The maintainer of the Hercules project explained on his blog why this was an attack on the Hercules project as a whole: http://ibmvshercules.com/