News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by war1025 on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @05:11PM (#24276164)
Thought about your reply a bit more.

If the movement were "Demilitarize the police", then yes, that is absolutely something I could be in favor of.

As it stands, "Defund the police" is to me a weasel word version of "Abolish the police" and I honestly do think people are just being coy when they claim not to see that.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by Zak on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @11:01PM (#24278653)
Most people using the word "defund" mean to reduce the level of funding for police and spend more on other social services. One argument is that police are not well equipped to provide services to people who are having a mental health, relationship, or substance abuse crisis and not actively doing violence. A mental health nurse or social worker might be a more appropriate first responder in situations that are not primarily characterized by violence.

There are a small but significant number of people in the current protests calling for policing as we know it to be abolished; they don't beat around the bush about it. The phrase "abolish the police" has 2.5 million google hits, a NYT op-ed, and a Wikipedia article.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by zaroth on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @11:23PM (#24278780)
Maybe they should carry signs that read “Fund social services” instead. The entire country has been through a traumatic event, coming at the heals of a massive opioid epidemic, I’m pretty sure it would be a unifying message that every American would support unequivocally.

Notably these funds don’t need to come at the expense of police funding.

We just dumped something like $5 trillion into a fire pit called COVID. There’s no lack of emergency funding for these programs if people demanded it.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by shirakawasuna on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:04AM (#24278994)
Defund also means balkanization of police duties. The police spend about 5% of their time on violent crime. They're also highly resistant to reforms and oversight. If we reduced police budgets by 80%, restricting their duties to those we consider necessary police work, they would be much smaller and easier to manage. The excess budget could go both to funding social services and to paying social workers, etc to do the other jobs that police currently do (and do badly).
Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by jjoonathan on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @05:17PM (#24276238)
It's a weasel word if they want to get rid of the police.

It's clickbait if they want to shift budgets.

I honestly have no idea whether it's primarily one vs the other.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by shirakawasuna on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:05AM (#24278996)
It's not a PR campaign. It wasn't planned for maximum effect or focus grouped. It's just what caught on.
Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by diffeomorphism on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @03:00AM (#24279887)
> If the movement were "Demilitarize the police", then yes, that is absolutely something I could be in favor of.

It is. Great that you support it.

> As it stands, "Defund the police" is to me a weasel word version of "Abolish the police"

So you understood the phrase wrong and now you know better.

TLDR: You support it but don't like the wording of the slogan.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by roenxi on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @04:48AM (#24280490)
There is a real risk in politics that people mean literally what they are saying.

There is a situation where a group of people have together under the slogan "defund the police". There is a very high risk that if they get the power to do something they will, literally and only, defund the police.

Not many people are reading policy documents. The point of unity in politics is usually the literal meaning of the words being used. Secret signals of "really we meant this other thing" tend not to work.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by diffeomorphism on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @06:41AM (#24281160)
There is nothing "secret" or "other thing" about it. You seem to think that "defund" secretly means "abolish". It doesn't. It means defund.
Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by roenxi on Thursday August 27, 2020 @04:34AM (#24291334)
Defund can easily mean abolish; there isn't really a feasible way to run a police force if they can't pay salaries. It is a literal reading of the phrase and in line with what some (hopefully a tiny minority) of protesters have been asking for.
Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by d0gbread on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @11:10PM (#24278707)
Why fret so much over the language though, that's what I don't understand. I think most people, of any POV, would agree it's not the best phrase given that without explanation it means what a small minority wants. Move past it, to the issue.
Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by war1025 on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @11:17PM (#24278746)
> Why fret so much over the language though

Because impressions matter, and if you want to get buy-in from an already weary broader populace, you need to have clear messaging.

Shouting "defund the police" in the middle of riots where innocent bystanders are attacked and businesses are looted is terrible messaging.

BLM have overplayed their hand at this point and are on the cusp of real public backlash.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by shirakawasuna on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:06AM (#24279003)
This is not a PR campaign and the protests and riots are not a public outreach effort. They are a demand coming from a position of pain and weariness.
Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by war1025 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:19AM (#24279071)
> This is not a PR campaign and the protests and riots are not a public outreach effort

Then they are utterly useless.

The way you phrased it, the protests are nothing more than tantrums by oversized children.

Tantrums should not be rewarded.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by shirakawasuna on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:24AM (#24279096)
> Then they are utterly useless

They've achieved many, though far from all, of their goals in various municipalities.

Why do you believe that a PR campaign is the only protest of value?

> The way you phrased it, the protests are nothing more than tantrums by oversized children.

That is in no way implied from how I phrased it. Pain and weariness from racialized murders and intimidation by cops is not a childish tantrum and I hope you never have to endure that pain yourself. I do hope that you find the empathy to consider their position.

> Tantrums should not be rewarded.

Please treat them like people.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by war1025 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @12:58AM (#24279263)
We are to some degree talking past each other.

You say the protests have achieved their goals. To me, that means they are an organized campaign of some sort.

The fact is, BLM is a national organization with nearly universal name recognition at this point. They have funding. They have PR teams. They are directing messaging.

And the fact remains that I think "Defund the Police" is terrible messaging.

> Please treat them like people.

As I said at the beginning, I think we're talking past each other.

I never meant to dehumanize the protesters.

The main point I am trying to make is that as someone with no horse in this race (i.e. I am neither pro-BLM nor pro-police) if I were forced to pick a side on the issue based on my current view of what is and has happened over the past couple months, I would come down on the side of the police. I'd rather just stay out of it.

All this said, as much as I think our politics differ, I really do respect the way you've responded to people in this thread, and I hope there are more people like you among the protesters because then maybe you've got an actual shot at achieving your goals.

Re:Gallup: 81% of Black Americans Want Police to Retain Loca... by shirakawasuna on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @01:19AM (#24279379)
> You say the protests have achieved their goals. To me, that means they are an organized campaign of some sort.

As in there are various demands by various groups and you can identify the core where they overlap.

> The fact is, BLM is a national organization with nearly universal name recognition at this point. They have funding. They have PR teams. They are directing messaging.

BLM is decentralized. They don't have most of that.

> And the fact remains that I think "Defund the Police" is terrible messaging.

Okay. But it's not PR. It's not some campaign crafted by an overpaid consultant. It's a decentralized protest movement. I don't want it to be that, either. That's part of the problem in politics - caring far too much about this kind of thing. Focus on the realities, the people dying. The violent and aggressive and frequently racist police.

> > Please treat them like people.

> As I said at the beginning, I think we're talking past each other.

I think the attempt to infantilize was nearly dehumanizing.

> I never meant to dehumanize the protesters.

Then stop calling protests in response to murders by police a tantrum by oversized children.

> The main point I am trying to make is that as someone with no horse in this race (i.e. I am neither pro-BLM nor pro-police)

We all have a horse in this race. We live together in a society that has some level of control over things like policing, equity, violence, crime, poverty. The "neutral" position is implicit support for the status quo, much as being a "moderate" in politics indicates the same.

> if I were forced to pick a side on the issue based on my current view of what is and has happened over the past couple months, I would come down on the side of the police. I'd rather just stay out of it.

As I said before, ha.

> All this said, as much as I think our politics differ, I really do respect the way you've responded to people in this thread, and I hope there are more people like you among the protesters because then maybe you've got an actual shot at achieving your goals.

The vast majority of people in the protests are like me. You should go to one.