"they just never made any improvements to their service"
I've observed the opposite. They constantly make improvements to their service.
They've got boatloads of features and they're getting better all the time.
If you guys can bring up examples, that would be helpful to the rest of us...
The account I bought initially had 15 MB space limit (it was a 15$ one time purchase for life membership). They never increased this limit... The web interface didn't auto refresh, unless you used "poll" which then only refreshed every 30 minutes.
When I did switch there was a bug in the forwarding that resulted in some of my emails not forwarding (although this went away and only happened to 3 emails).
They might have had better improvements for accounts that required continuous payment, but certainly not mine. It obviously got surpassed by free alternatives.
Despite this criticism, I am very satisfied with fastmail, they served me well for a long time.
10+ years ago I payed a small fee for life time account with them, and they very were good, but they just never made any improvements to their service and gmail just got better and better to the point it seemed ridiculous to keep using fastmail.