Yeah, his self-aggrandizing can be tiresome. He does sound like a one person cult from time to time. But he has been tireless in saying the one important thing "This fight can be won. Don't let up. It is worth fighting". And that in itself is worth our respect.
Now, I have long come to the conclusion that there are no technical solutions to this. Only political ones. In the sense that at the micro level we need to create the movement of people that care. At the macro level we need to elect the people that pass the laws that break the megacorps or make them into public utilities. It doesn't mean we stop working on the software infrastructure to combat the Evil empire(s). But software alone won't cut it.
Now Aral is not useless on those tlfights either. He keeps talking about them, and talks well.
So, will Site.js make any dent in anything? Quite obviously not. Personally, technically, most of it makes me cringe quite violently.
Could it have had a better chance if Aral was "nicer", humbler, at a bit better at coalition building? Probably.
At any rate, Aral, not being "nice" is no reason to be nasty yourself.
Best of luck Aral, keep up the fight, and thank you for your service.
You could join any ActivityPub based project; even start one; build a Matrix client with a web frontent; dig into Scuttlebutt; start working with Beaker on dat://. Any of these choices are better, than starting yet another approach from scratch and wasting a lot of time and effort on it.
Now, for the other issue: please don't try to coin new term that is confusing to everyone. For example, there was a brilliant essay recently - https://neustadt.fr/essays/the-small-web/ - which used the same "small web" phrase in a very different context. This is just the tip of the iceberg with the problem of using something this generic.
I think tooling around this idea makes sense and I hope you succeed.
I wrote a little allegorical story about this which you might like: https://zalberico.com/essay/2020/07/14/the-serfs-of-facebook...
I think it's a hard problem and it's exciting to see multiple projects trying to make this better: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24269016
Yes, and that's good. We need harsh places.
Just skimmed the comments (I know, I know, never read the comments) but here are couple of facts in case you care about that sort of thing (but please don’t let these get in the way of a lively discussion) ;)
Also, PS:Small Web is not about having your own Static Web page or having yet another tool for geeks. It’s not about going back to the 90s (been there, was fun, wouldn’t want to go back), it’s about taking the best of that ethos and implementing it for 2020 and beyond. Right now, I’m trying to build a tool for developers (including us) so that we can use it to build everything things for everyday people that don’t require a Faustian pact to give up your privacy, freedom of speech, or your personhood to use.
Whether or not this “succeeds”, who knows? But we’re sharing everything we make under AGPL and trying to share every brick in this bridge we’re trying to build between where we are (the sewer that is surveillance capitalism) and where we want to be in hopes that if the stuff we build doesn’t work, at least others can use the tools to build other solutions.
Here’s a recent talk if you’d like to learn more about what we’re working on:
https://small-tech.org/videos/eastern-partnership-civil-soci...
You don’t have to like what we do and you definitely don’t have to like me but I do hope that you will consider the ideas (and ideals) we’re working towards.