News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by jmnicolas on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @02:36AM (#24268652)
You can conceptualize all you want about dog fights, the truth is nobody wants to be the pilot having fired all the missiles and having nothing left to engage the remaining enemy planes.

It's a bit like saying a soldier doesn't need a bayonet / combat knife. 99.99999% of the time yes, but would you bet YOUR life on it?

Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by namdnay on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @02:57AM (#24268746)
The question isn’t “do pilots want it”, it’s “does the taxpayer want it”?
Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @10:06AM (#24271464)
Since there is military competition between countries, it’s more like, if we choose A and China chooses B, are we still at an advantage or will China overwhelm our superior trained manned fighters with lots of cheap drones?
Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by Voliokis on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @03:18AM (#24268851)
I get the line of thought and the idea of inflated military budgets but I'm not sure your average Joe should get any say in whether a new weapons system should be funded or not. They have no military expertise and no concept of what might be necessary to win the next war. While I do think there needs to be more oversight over how budgets are allotted to military projects, it shouldn't be decided by "do taxpayers want to pay".
Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by salawat on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @08:32AM (#24270642)
So, you're a fan of military juntas then? That's what you get when you remove a civilian guiding hand from military policymaking. I'll give you that civilians absolutely need to keep their nose out of the how, but guidance in terms of the what is absolutely essential. Otherwise you get the MacArthurs of the world calling the shots.

The military industrial complex is absolutely a beast that requires oversight and restraint. Just as the intelligence complex does. I wish more people understood and appreciated it. It doesn't need to be dismantled by a long shot necessarily, but BS needs to be called.

Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by Voliokis on Thursday August 27, 2020 @05:01AM (#24291506)
I'm sure there are civilian experts and they absolutely should be involved, as well as elected representatives who are (preferably) guided by experts. Your average citizen has no business chiming in.
Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by adrianN on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @10:27AM (#24271662)
How much of a chance do you have if you don't have missiles, but your enemy still has some? Isn't it better to just retreat?
Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by foxyv on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @01:55PM (#24274024)
If you are within a certain distance you can stay outside of the weapons engagement zone for missiles. Retreating at that point presents a target for a short range missile. Missiles are great in themselves because they force your enemy to stay out of your WEZ while you are slotting in for a guns kill.

If they try to extend out for a better turn rate you hit them with the missile. If they turn too hard they lose energy and you can gun them. The fights tend to end earlier because it's so much easier to make a mistake.

Also with missiles, countermeasures can be employed which are pretty effective. Can't fit much brain in a 40G missile that is mostly solid rocket and explosives. Missile warning systems and automatic countermeasures are remarkably effective. Not so much against 30mm

Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by gomox on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @11:39AM (#24272459)
If your enemy still has missiles and you proceed to give him ample time to shoot them at your tail while you peacefully retreat, you might regret the approach.
Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by adrianN on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @11:54AM (#24272609)
I know very little about air-to-air combat, but I had the impression that the effective range of missiles is such that you'd have a hard time reaching your enemy before they had ample time to fire at you.
Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by jmnicolas on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @03:44PM (#24275239)
Having a cannon instead of nothing gives you possibilities, like having a Swiss army knife in a jungle survival scenario.

Yes you're probably going to die, but at least you are not a sitting duck.

They even give pilots a pistol or a sub-machine gun in case they eject over enemy territory. It's probably dead weight, but if it can save someone once, why not? I wouldn't go without it even if intellectually I know I'm not going to take down the whole enemy army with a 15 shots pistol.

Re:Navy F/A-18 squadron commander's take on AI repeatedly be... by ardy42 on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @12:51PM (#24273336)
> How much of a chance do you have if you don't have missiles, but your enemy still has some? Isn't it better to just retreat?

It probably depends on the situation and what you do. IIRC, missiles lose effectiveness at the kinds of short ranges where you'd use guns. In some situations, running might put you in a more vulnerable situation while closing to a gunfight might even things up.