Re:Challenge to scientists: does your ten-year-old code stil...
by BeetleB on Monday August 24, 2020 @02:27PM
(#24263753)
> The only case where the code would be used (which is a valid reason why it should be available somehow) is to assert that your particular results are flawed or fraudulent;
Not true. Code is often used and reused to churn out a lot more results than the initial paper. A flaw in the code doesn't just show one paper/result as problematic. It can show a large chunk of a researcher's work in his area of expertise to be problematic.
The only case where the code would be used (which is a valid reason why it should be available somehow) is to assert that your particular results are flawed or fraudulent; otherwise the quality of the code (or its availability, or even existence - perhaps you could have had a bunch of people do all of it on paper without any code) is simply irrelevant if you want your results to be usable by others.