News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top colleges should select randomly from a pool of ‘good ... by notacoward on Monday August 24, 2020 @09:02AM (#24260192)
Meritocracy does not require strict ranking of individuals. Selecting cohorts instead of individuals is still meritocracy. You could use weighted probabilities, with higher scores meaning higher probabilities but still short of certainty, and it would still be meritocracy. The OP's point is that when measurement error is as large as it is for college admissions, using a simple lottery to narrow the cohort is as good as any other method wrt getting the best students, and better in terms of fairness/diversity. Not saying it's correct, or that "meritocracy" as it exists now is something we must preserve, but "it's not meritocracy" isn't true.
Re:Top colleges should select randomly from a pool of ‘good ... by username90 on Monday August 24, 2020 @05:39PM (#24265835)
> The OP's point is that when measurement error is as large as it is for college admissions, using a simple lottery to narrow the cohort is as good as any other method wrt getting the best students

Not really. Lets say every student scores within 10 percentage point of their true "merit". So if you only pick the top 1% scorers you actually could get students down in the top 11%. So why not just pick top 11% by random? Because when you pick a top 11% scorer you extend your range so you now could get as low as top 21%. Ranking them still matters quite a lot even if error range is larger than their pick range.

Re:Top colleges should select randomly from a pool of ‘good ... by rhino369 on Monday August 24, 2020 @06:34PM (#24266314)
You can pick a different random set of inputs and come to the opposite conclusion.

It could be true that there is no correlation between true "merit" and test scores when you get to, say, the 99%th percentile. Especially since the predictive ability of these tests must be suspect now that you can study strategies for them.

In that situation, Harvard shouldn't value a 1600 any more than a 1540.