Re:Some Ugly Code Can Get Nvidia's Linux Driver Working with...
by bitwize on Monday August 24, 2020 @01:30AM
(#24257758)
How about "X is insecure, flaky, unsupported, and solves problems nobody actually has"? Such is the considered opinion of just about anybody who knows spit about the Linux graphics stack. Hint: The major Wayland devs are former Xorg devs.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Some Ugly Code Can Get Nvidia's Linux Driver Working with...
by wander_homer on Monday August 24, 2020 @02:11AM
(#24257924)
I don't see how Wayland would improve security in my case. There are basically two types of applications on my system: some which can't be used in sandboxes in a reasonable way and those which work well in sandboxes. In the first case I wouldn't gain anything with Wayland because my shellrc, launcher configuration, ssh keys, personal data, ... are accessible to those applications, giving them and a potential attacker basically full access to my system, including the control of all Wayland clients.
In the second case, those applications work well with X security extensions and X11 proxies so I'm pretty fine in that regard, even with X11.
And since X11 also works just so much better in the majority of cases I care about, regarding my productivity and flexibility, I don't see any reason to use Wayland right now.
Re:Some Ugly Code Can Get Nvidia's Linux Driver Working with...
by viraptor on Monday August 24, 2020 @01:56AM
(#24257869)
For some of us X just works right now and the security issue isn't urgent. (For serious impact someone would have to break out of browser sandbox and then spy... on the browser)
In theory I'd like to move to Wayland, but X solves my problem which is "I want to see windows, some of them accelerated".
Re:Some Ugly Code Can Get Nvidia's Linux Driver Working with...
by AceJohnny2 on Monday August 24, 2020 @02:41AM
(#24258049)
> Hint: The major Wayland devs are former Xorg devs.
But notably, major Xorg developer Keith Packard is missing from that list.
Re:Some Ugly Code Can Get Nvidia's Linux Driver Working with...
by bitwize on Monday August 24, 2020 @11:54AM
(#24261835)
Agreed, which means that right now Keith Packard is about the only person or entity keeping X alive. Red Hat have washed their hands of it. When the legacy versions of RHEL that still use it go out of support, maintenance on Xorg will pretty much grind to a halt. It is a moribund project, and that presents considerable risk.