News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mojuba on Thursday July 10, 2008 @10:55AM (#242444)
Then there's reason @ (@ comes before the letter A, right?) -

@) iPod is a closed proprietary gadget that can only be accessed using closed proprietary software. If iPod was open and standardized, the rest of your reasons would probably magically disappear.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mechanical_fish on Thursday July 10, 2008 @11:20AM (#242476)
Ah, you mean that Apple should release a system based on completely open standards, so that it can be easily cloned by former employees of Apple's own Chinese manufacturing partners and brought to market at a lower price? A process which, when iterated, will eventually shave margins down to razor-thin levels, lead to an erosion of good design and the proliferation of generic, bad design, and threaten to drive Apple out of its own industry?

That sure worked out well for IBM in the PC industry. Whereas the folks who specialized in selling closed, proprietary PC operating systems didn't do well at all.

Not that I wouldn't love a completely open music player that provided the same user experience as iTunes and the iPod. But, oddly, despite the existence of lots of cheap MP3 players, the majority of them have a kind of generic, bad design -- and those that don't sell at low enough volumes that they have trouble competing in price with iPods. And their market is fragmented enough that they don't achieve the kind of dominance that -- for example -- leads to podcast pages having a special button just for them, the way many pages have a special "listen with iTunes" button.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by icey on Thursday July 10, 2008 @01:18PM (#242654)
news.YC: May contain capitalism.

(p.s. You're totally right)

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by raganwald on Thursday July 10, 2008 @10:59AM (#242449)
I don't understand. If iPod was "open and standardized" in 1991, how would Apple have built an iTunes Music Store that would have provided the same experience?

Or are you arguing that instead, they should have built something using the "open and standardized" components of the day, precluding almost all of the functionality that made it successful?

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by t0pj on Thursday July 10, 2008 @11:30AM (#242492)
iPod was "open and standardized" in 1991

1991 was a sweet year for the iPod and iTunes. I had no issues installing it on MS-DOS 4/Windows 3.1 but had a hard time with corrupted data when connecting it up via centronix cable (I think iTunes also used a dBase III back-end at the time).

:)

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by raganwald on Thursday July 10, 2008 @11:51AM (#242537)
But you must admit, it looked great on a Hercules Graphics Adaptor.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by Xichekolas on Thursday July 10, 2008 @02:47PM (#242751)
Yeah, I really enjoying listening to my iPod during SSR (Sustained Silent Reading) in the 2nd grade.

But then my teacher took it away... muttering something about "kids these days and their technology from the future"

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mechanical_fish on Thursday July 10, 2008 @11:29AM (#242488)
I think you mean "2001", not "1991". </nitpick>

And I, too, find it funny that people are still arguing for Apple to pursue the business model that its nigh-extinct competitors were already pursuing in 2001 when the iPod came out.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mojuba on Thursday July 10, 2008 @11:32AM (#242498)
Not the gadget itself, but rather access to it. iPod/iTunes is an isolated system designed to lock you in, which makes sense from the business point of view, is legal, gives more confidence to content providers and after all, is beneficial to the company. That's OK.

I'm arguing that Apple wouldn't have to be anti-Web if iPod was more open and allowed any software to connect and exchange content with it. That's against the grain for Apple, I'm sure, but that's their problem, not mine. (And the irony is that I'm typing this on a Mac)

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by pchristensen on Thursday July 10, 2008 @12:08PM (#242558)
How is that against the grain for Apple? Apple is known for design and quality but I never thought of them as especially open. Sure, they argued for openness where it served them as a 3% player in the OS space, but now that they're a 70+% player in music, more openness would hurt them.

Openness hurts the big boys, so you hardly ever see the big boys pushing for it. Google is happy to be open with the contents of the entire Web, but not with any aspect of their own business (hiring practices, pictures of campus, PageRank formula, infrastructure, etc).

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by raganwald on Thursday July 10, 2008 @12:36PM (#242595)
> Google is happy to be open with the contents of the entire Web, but not with any aspect of their own business (hiring practices, pictures of campus, PageRank formula, infrastructure, etc).

IIRC, Joel Spolsky called this "commoditizing your complement."

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mojuba on Thursday July 10, 2008 @12:49PM (#242614)
Google is happy to be open with the contents of the entire Web

I'm not sure what you mean. Google is gradually opening its technology - you see one announcement after another these days.

And here lies the difference between Google and Apple: both benefited from the open-source world big time, except the former contributes back as an acknowledgement, and the latter contributes nothing.

Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by neodude on Thursday July 10, 2008 @11:09PM (#243191)
What about WebKit and Darwin, to name a few?
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mojuba on Friday July 11, 2008 @05:11AM (#243372)
Both are derived from non-Apple open-source projects and thus must be open.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by LogicHoleFlaw on Friday July 11, 2008 @01:07PM (#243747)
Darwin at least has roots in BSD which does not obligate the user to open derived works.
Re:ITunes is Anti-Web by mojuba on Friday July 11, 2008 @08:02PM (#244169)
That's the kernel... Darwin's userland is GNU.