News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Devel... by ncmncm on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:33PM (#24237573)
The following corrections to fundamental factual errors should not distract one from the meat of the article:

1. Jet engines, like car engines, are not described by the "Carnot cycle", and their efficiency is not governed by it. The Carnot cycle describes closed-system equipment like refrigerators and Nuke plants. Jet engines, like (our now obsolete) cars, start with new working fluid -- air -- at the intake, and discard it at the end -- exhaust. Their theoretical limit of efficiency is technically 100%, not the 30-40% typical of Carnot equipment. In practice, they don't get close, but those huge ship engines do achieve up to 55%: they all take in air much, much cooler than their exhaust.

2. The change to the thrust vector is not a consequence of moving the engines forward. It is a simple result of the bigger engine diameter making the center farther below the wing. Moving the engines forward and up reduced the size of the change to the thrust vector -- just not enough so to match the old one. But the move had other effects, besides...

3. The added aerodynamic lift of the engine nacelles has nothing to do with more power being produced by the bigger engines. It is purely a product of the angle relative to the direction of air moving past. Bigger barrels have more area, and more lift, and moving them forward gave them more lever arm to apply their lift to rotate the plane instead of just holding it up, as wing lift does.

4. The change to the thrust vector is what makes punching the throttle also apply a force to rotate the airframe to a higher pitch angle. So there are two independent forces -- off-center lift, and off-center thrust -- both causing the same effect: pitching the plane up more than the pilot asked for. How much you get of each is a very complicated product of all the details of how the plane is flying.

5. On all 737s of any vintage, the controls really are still directly, physically connected, by steel cables, to the control surfaces -- the hinged bits at the back edges of wings and wing-shaped things. But there are hydraulics that also yank on the cables, and other stuff yanks on the control column, to doctor the pilot's experience.

There are no comments on this comment yet.