Re:Telegram messaging app proves crucial to Belarus protests
by godelski on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:36PM
(#24237611)
Also an important aspect is that it is open sourced, meaning others can audit it. I'm a little untrusting of people that say "trust me" but also "no, you can't look at it." (unless there is a good reason to hide it, which in this case I do not believe there is)
Re:Telegram messaging app proves crucial to Belarus protests
by maqp on Saturday August 22, 2020 @02:33AM
(#24242164)
The thing is, there's nothing to audit.
The world's best audit of Telegram would make the following obvious findings:
1. It's not E2EE by default therefore it's not private and secure by default.
2. It's not E2EE at all for groups therefore it's not safe for use of dissident groups
3. It's not E2EE at all for desktop clients therefore it's not practical in daily messaging.
Any audit of the E2EE part is meaningless when E2EE is so impractical it's not used by users at all.
Re:Telegram messaging app proves crucial to Belarus protests
by jhasse on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:23PM
(#24239947)
MTproto is also open source.
Re:Telegram messaging app proves crucial to Belarus protests
by godelski on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:57PM
(#24240640)
Thank you for updating. For those curious this is what I found looking for the source https://github.com/tdlib/td/tree/80c35676a2eb1e9b71db355ee21...
Re:Telegram messaging app proves crucial to Belarus protests
by upofadown on Friday August 21, 2020 @03:25PM
(#24238052)
It's based on the concepts of OTR but it has gone in different directions to actually implement those ideas.
Re:Telegram messaging app proves crucial to Belarus protests
by maqp on Saturday August 22, 2020 @02:34AM
(#24242169)
(DH-ratchet is still there. 1536-bit FF-DH was replaced with X3DH etc, but the basic idea is still there. Adding hash ratchet for non-round-trip messaging was a good idea, as was pre-keys stored on server. IMO it's fair to say it's been expanded around OTR)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signal_Protocol