News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:India's skewed sex ratio by dmm on Friday April 08, 2011 @07:50AM (#2423349)
I wouldn't worry. Human societies have very effective methods for dealing with excess men.

Here's a popular one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War

EDIT: I really am worried. This is a terrible situation and one which I could see as getting much worse.

Re:India's skewed sex ratio by die_sekte on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:08AM (#2423404)
China also has excess men. And India and China already have a territorial conflict. If there is a third world war, it's probably going to be there.
Re:India's skewed sex ratio by iwwr on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:16AM (#2423419)
Perhaps a rehash of the theft of the Sabines.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rape_of_the_Sabine_Women

Re:India's skewed sex ratio by michaelty on Friday April 08, 2011 @09:11AM (#2423584)
Re:India's skewed sex ratio by dimmuborgir on Friday April 08, 2011 @11:19AM (#2424144)
There's a strong perception in both China and India (mostly in China) that the future war between China and India will be triggered by none other than western countries! :-P
Re:India's skewed sex ratio by gsk on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:56AM (#2423526)
Well, that's one of looking at it. However, I think, we must not discount cultural factors that play a part on how a society deals with it. Some societies arrive at a more pacifist solution such as Polyandry. Societies in the state of Kerala (and other as well) had Polyandry as a social arrangement at some point in history, I believe, partly as a result of skewed sex ratios.
Re:India's skewed sex ratio by bdhe on Friday April 08, 2011 @10:49AM (#2424004)
> Societies in the state of Kerala ...

This is very very interesting because right now, due to a lot of education and a relatively higher standard of living Kerala can boast of a sex ratio of 1084 females/1000 males the only state in India with more females than males.

Also, Kerala is famously a stronghold of a Communist Party (the Communist Party of India (Marxist)).

Re:India's skewed sex ratio by rauljara on Friday April 08, 2011 @07:57AM (#2423367)
I wouldn't worry about [terrible thing]. There are natural responses to [terrible thing] that are fully foreseeable consequences of [terrible thing]. One of them is [even more terrible thing].
Re:India's skewed sex ratio by iwwr on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:23AM (#2423442)
Strangely, Western response to famine or war in impoverished countries has tended to exacerbate (or even create) the crises at hand. Doing something may be seen as a sensible thing, but perhaps Africa would have been better off if the West did nothing to help. Even though it involves the least effort, doing nothing is categorically the toughest thing.
Re:India's skewed sex ratio by bluekeybox on Friday April 08, 2011 @09:53AM (#2423759)
Good point, but the worst interventions had been of a military kind, and I don't think the grandparent has a military intervention in mind.
Re:India's skewed sex ratio by jerf on Friday April 08, 2011 @11:22AM (#2424157)
It's easy to see how bad military interventions are. You have bodies with a clear line of responsibility back to the war, destroyed buildings, etc.

What's the cost of inept Western assistance to Africa when it actively impedes them developing their own civilization, accidentally enforcing poverty and propping up terrible governments? This, too, destroys wealth and lives, up to and including killing people, but it's a lot harder to see. It is, nevertheless, real. Real people are really dying and living in nightmare states.

Which is really worse? I don't have an answer, which is my point. It's hard to tell. But it's possible to rack up death tolls with non-"military intervention" that can put most military interventions to shame.

Re:India's skewed sex ratio by bluekeybox on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:16PM (#2425005)
> It's easy to see how bad military interventions are...

Yes, except replace the word "easy" with "can be measured." Once you get into the domain of things that cannot be measured (or "not easy to see" as you say, presumingly requiring interpretation -- by whom?), you lose the empirical ground, and thus anything you say becomes close to worthless. I would rather stick to things that can be measured and not require speculation.

An authentic non-Western civilization in Africa is a very beautiful dream, but there is one huge problem to it: guns are effective and can be smuggled, whether by white people or black people or whoever.

Try looking at the spread of Christianity in Africa. Suppose there were no Western missionaries. Would we have had a "more authentic Africa" then? Probably not, we would have likely ended up with a "more Islamic Africa" instead. But don't dwell too much on this because it is just another of those "would" things that can't be measured.

Re:India's skewed sex ratio by jerf on Friday April 08, 2011 @03:04PM (#2425172)
I don't particularly care about "authenticity" of any culture. I don't really think there is a such thing. I'm strictly talking about how aid has had negative impact, so when I talk about them not forming "their own civilization" I simply mean their inability to date to successfully form stable governments, civil services, etc., regardless of their structural details. There are probably ways of giving aid that would have not had negative effects, though it's hard to know.