News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Notes from a Flat Earth Conference by shadowgovt on Thursday August 20, 2020 @12:03PM (#24224650)
I wonder if you had a strategy for reconciling the theory of the flat moon with flat Earth?

Believing in both at the same time is extra-tricky, and that's what caused me to get banned from the Facebook flat-Earthers. If the moon is flat, perspective distortion should make it disk-like, and nobody's observed a disk-like moon. So either the moon is round (and the fact it only shows us one face is some extra-fancy trickery with mirrors or lenses or something), or the moon is a flat disk facing Earth, but the Earth is a ball rotating under the moon.

(Clarification: none of this is things I believe. I spent time debating flat-Earthers as an exercise in logical consistency and alignment with observational evidence).

Re:Notes from a Flat Earth Conference by manfredo on Thursday August 20, 2020 @12:17PM (#24224822)
Even if the moon were a disk, the angle it makes relative to a normal vector coming out from ground demonstrates a spherical earth.

You don't even need to factor in the moon, this can be done with the stars. In a flat earth, the same stars would be visible when you're in the southern too of south America as in the northernmost top of north America. This isn't the case since the earth is spherical.

Heck, even just the timing of a sunrise is sufficient. In a flat earth the sun would rise simultaneously across the globe... er, disk. But of course that's not the case. It's daytime in half of the world at any given time.

Re:Notes from a Flat Earth Conference by Humdeee on Thursday August 20, 2020 @12:33PM (#24225008)
I have no clue about any arguments flat earthers make, but I am curious how they would object to some of the fundamental concepts like you provided. I suppose it doesn't make much sense that they would use science to refute your points...
Re:Notes from a Flat Earth Conference by minxomat on Thursday August 20, 2020 @02:28PM (#24226690)
The gist of that is in the article. They never need and rarely do object to "fundamental concepts". Rather, they object to what they perceive to be your belief in them. That way, they never have to address anything directly.
Re:Notes from a Flat Earth Conference by manfredo on Thursday August 20, 2020 @12:35PM (#24225038)
Personally I think that it's just the limits of geometric understanding for some peole. Personally I hit that limit when I tried to understand quaternions. Some people hit that limit with calculus. I guess others hit that limit when they try to understand perspective from a sphere.
Re:Notes from a Flat Earth Conference by giomasce on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:51PM (#24228791)
They invent new scientific rules. With two caveats: first, the new rules are not independently tested by experiment (maybe they are vaguely justified by thought experiment; thought by them); second, their rules are just qualitative, nearly never quantitative, so that they basically everything can be true.

So, measuring angles is off limits. Then they admit you cannot see things that are far away and close to the horizon, but not by curvature. By perspective: perspective laws, they say, mandate that far away objects become very small, too small to be seen. Do you basically can see only a limited part of the sky, at a sufficiently high angle from the horizon on the flat earth. That is why you can't see the whole sky.