News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Didn't get in YC S11? Are you going to charge for... by cdgreen1 on Thursday April 07, 2011 @11:30PM (#2422299)
Wow! Very interesting. You'll have a kick butt team and two successful apps (Groups and Calender) that I know people use all the time. It would be interesting to see how the selection process works.
Re:Ask HN: Didn't get in YC S11? Are you going to charge for... by EGreg on Thursday April 07, 2011 @11:57PM (#2422373)
Yeah I have no idea why they didn't even want to interview us.

I mean, I saw the batch of YC companies in winter 2010. I would humbly like to say that we seem to be closer to what YC says they are looking for, than several of those companies were.

For example, we applied in Winter 2010, YC rejected us without an interview, and then we went ahead and secured investment and launched and already have 80k users and nearly all ratings are 5/5 . Our apps are being used 30k times a day (in aggregate) so engagement is high. Not only that, but we are already generating profit. YC says they like entrepreneurs that hang in there.

Also, they say they like people who achieved a lot. I was a concert pianist when I was a kid and went to college at 14. ( http://magarshak.com ). I normally don't say that but I thought I might as well just mention it. So I have no idea how their selection process works. If they had any concerns about the company, I would have been happy to talk to them in person. I think we at least would have warranted an interview.

I personally think YC made a "wrong decision". But it may very well be that the selection process has other things that I am not aware of. For example, they may have so many applicants that they are looking for specific things they did NOT mention on the site, and these may be weighted more heavily.

Anyway, we are a bit surprised, but that's about it :)

Re:Ask HN: Didn't get in YC S11? Are you going to charge for... by charlieconroy on Friday April 08, 2011 @12:21PM (#2424464)
Ha!, I think all of us rejected think personally YC made the wrong decision.

[Edit] I did not want to seem like a jerk with just leaving a jab. Continue to grow your company and listen to your users and don't focus on hypothetical reasons why yc did not choose you.

Re:Ask HN: Didn't get in YC S11? Are you going to charge for... by helwr on Sunday April 10, 2011 @06:57AM (#2429292)
Why do you need YC?