You don’t have ‘real’ private firms doing work, you end up with these professional gov contractor companies (who focus entirely on gov projects) which act like half baked gov agencies themselves with none of the public oversight/responsibility to tax payers and government agencies acting like profit seeking entities with no competition and bottom feeding talent pools/lowest price contracts (which almost always ends up being flakey organizations mentioned earlier who are entirely designed to get gov contracts as mentioned earlier).
Beyond that, the inherent structure of using a patchwork of consultancies with broken responsibility chains and corrupted incentive structures also kills many over-capitalized tech startups too. It’s a poor way to build any business.
Much like Apple the only things that should be outsourced are manageable isolated pieces, not core parts of the project.
You also can see why people are pro-gutting public agencies when these disasters are all they can produce - while at the same time there are certain areas private firms won’t naturally account for. The whole thing needs a rethinking.
With public infrastructure projects like roads and railways, why should one go for a purely private infrastructure? The only reason for this is if corrupt politicians want kickbacks from rent seekers (for example like the private prison which paid off a judge).
> Much like Apple the only things that should be outsourced are manageable isolated pieces, not core parts of the project.
Actually Apple proves that you can outsource the core part (manufacturing) - provided you have the in house staff for management and oversight of the project. The only lapse in quality stemming from a lack of oversight is the NVIDIA GPU debacle back a decade ago, but to be fair: that one bit the whole industry.
> You also can see why people are pro-gutting public agencies when these disasters are all they can produce - while at the same time there are certain areas private firms won’t naturally account for.
The reason for people (in practice: Republicans) wanting to gut and then privatize public agencies is, as I wrote above, corruption. Demolish the funding during the last days of a Republican presidency, have it take effect during the Democrat term, then campaign with "we should privatize XYZ, it doesn't work", win the vote, privatize XYZ, get kickbacks / "donations".
An old, tried and tested playbook, and for what it's worth not even US-specific - our German Conservative party is a real expert at that, too...
I’m fine with tax money going entirely to public run firms. I just may disagree on what areas the government should be getting involved in - which is most things outside of a few obvious like public infrastructure, healthcare insurance, law enforcement/justice system, etc where private incentive structures, real competition (see the phoney US health insurance ‘competition’), and where other functions of markets don’t exist or will practically excel.
Suppose the FBI wants to build an office in Texarkana. Are they supposed to directly hire a bunch of people in Texarkana? Should the people who install the carpet get an exemption from the agency's normal background check, medical exam, and firearms training? Hiring competent people requires competent managers, in this case for construction, so they'd need to hire before they can hire. Suppose the EPA also decides to build an office in Texarkana. Does the EPA need to directly hire people too, maybe competing with the FBI and trying to swipe employees?
There is also the huge issue of government workforce rules. In the business world, bad employees tend to get fired. Businesses don't last if they tolerate too many bad employees, which effectively fires the whole company. Government isn't about to shut down, and there are numerous rules which make it near-impossible to get rid of worthless and negative-value employees. Hiring is also limited by low pay. Corruption thrives when pay is below the norm for the market. The competent people won't stay. It's a miracle government can function at all. Raising the pay gets taxpayers furious, in part because taxpayers see the corruption and incompetence.
The answer is thus, sadly, to minimize the problem by minimizing the employees. There isn't a better choice that is realistic.
Why not have a central federal agency that does the oversight and planning for all other federal agencies, with local experts in all 50 states that know local building codes and maintain relationships with vendors? That way the agencies don't have individual high costs for the controlling/planning yet benefit from shared knowledge and from having experts that prevent them from getting ripped off.
> Government isn't about to shut down, and there are numerous rules which make it near-impossible to get rid of worthless and negative-value employees.
That one has been solved by many other countries. Reform said rules from the ground up, that's it. There are enough examples to copy from.
> Hiring is also limited by low pay.
The low pay is caused by shrinking budgets, so having multiple government agencies join forces can reduce the individual costs while still maintaining decent competitive payment for staff.
This is what I don't like with American big business: everybody hires consultants, who then subcontract consultants, who then subcontract consultants, who then subcontract consultants.
And in the end it comes to nobody knows anything, despite n-times of my annual salary being spent every few weeks.
Where are those experts really, why they are not being hired instead of the type of "experts" whose only competence is to hire another consultant?
At the bottom of the ladder in the chain.
> why they are not being hired instead of the type of "experts" whose only competence is to hire another consultant?
Because the actual experts don't have experience in how to properly react to government tenders or the political connections to have tenders written so that only a specific company or two match it, and because public sector HR does not have any way of actually evaluating experts (as the historical knowledge of senior employees all got removed).
So it's the same problem that plagues government and megacorp IT and construction worldwide: they depend on external entities for oversight, QA and controlling of the vendors instead of having the appropriate knowledge and staff in-house.
That's what happens when public sector employees get gutted to "save costs". The politicians who decided this decades ago are no longer there and cannot be held accountable for the consequences, and we are stuck with the fallout.