Re:Most “mandatory requirements” in corporations are imaginary
by gwd on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:17AM
(#24209197)
So the company I work for made the front page of HN last year for a security breach. I won't go into details, but I will say one factor was a particular instance where security was overlooked for many years due to convenience.
In response, the company has now sort of swung the other way: lots of things that have a perfectly valid reason and are reasonably safe have been forbidden or suddenly have needed to be justified in the face of extreme skepticism.
That wasn't a case of a single engineer causing 100x engineers worth of damage, but it was the case where something made hundreds of people's jobs a tiny bit easier for two decades, then caused a massive public loss of face and who knows how much reputational damage.
And I'd be willing to bet that a fair number of HN readers work at a company which has at least one system with similar properties (a bit more convenient, a bit less secure) to the one implicated in our security breach; but failure is a once-a-decade event, and their company isn't nearly that old yet. Would those engineers defend that setup using the argument from this article?
In response, the company has now sort of swung the other way: lots of things that have a perfectly valid reason and are reasonably safe have been forbidden or suddenly have needed to be justified in the face of extreme skepticism.
That wasn't a case of a single engineer causing 100x engineers worth of damage, but it was the case where something made hundreds of people's jobs a tiny bit easier for two decades, then caused a massive public loss of face and who knows how much reputational damage.
And I'd be willing to bet that a fair number of HN readers work at a company which has at least one system with similar properties (a bit more convenient, a bit less secure) to the one implicated in our security breach; but failure is a once-a-decade event, and their company isn't nearly that old yet. Would those engineers defend that setup using the argument from this article?