News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Problems in Robotics by jaaron on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @03:02AM (#24207904)
What do you think the error bounds are for a human?

I know it sounds like a flippant question, but for certain applications, if we can get a model that's better than human, then it doesn't need to be perfect.

And they way we currently do this in all sorts of ways is to pair a human with a computer so that they each do what they're best at. It doesn't have to be about full automation.

Re:Open Problems in Robotics by de_watcher on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @05:30AM (#24208644)
Human is like your ancient software that was here since forever and somewhat worked fine. So everyone is used to it.

(the difference from an actual software is that humans are based on some crazy nanotech from the future that nobody can completely control)

Re:Open Problems in Robotics by tomxor on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:32AM (#24210159)
> humans are based on some crazy nanotech from the future that nobody can completely control

Excellent summary :D

Re:Open Problems in Robotics by tomp on Thursday August 20, 2020 @02:47AM (#24220557)
This is another one of that "extreme tail risk" scenarios, like climate change and GMOs, that people have wildly different and contradictory reactions to.

Sure, the "legacy" intelligence / climate / food could also have extreme tail risks, it's just that it's been tested for 100s of millenia... whereas new technology might be better in the average case or even 99th percentile, but the 1% (or 0.0001%) is unknown and potentially much worse.

However, it seems to me that people resolve this more along ideological / political lines than with any kind of rational reasoning.

Re:Open Problems in Robotics by jnxx on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:51PM (#24236584)
> "extreme tail risk" scenarios, like climate change

Climate change isn't a "tail risk". It is a hard wall our civilization is approaching fast. If we do not solve it, it will undo the conditions we depend on to live.