News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Modeling a Wealth Tax by WalterBright on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @05:00PM (#24204282)
Nobody sits on cash. Even cash on deposit in a bank isn't in the bank - a multiple of it gets loaned out to businesses and home buyers.
Re:Modeling a Wealth Tax by refurb on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @05:10PM (#24204382)
Indeed. On most balance sheets it's "cash and cash equivalents". Apple owns treasuries and other "highly liquid assets" that are regarded as cash equivalents.

Apple had $12B in true cash at the end of Q3'19.[1] But the "cost of revenue" was $163B. So they had ~7% of expenses available as cash, which makes sense since you don't want to be selling short-term investments to make payroll. You'd need to keep cash on hand to pay expenses.

[1]https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL/financials?p=AAPL

Re:Modeling a Wealth Tax by WalterBright on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @05:15PM (#24204439)
They still don't have any cash. None. Cash on deposit isn't cash, either. It is not in the bank, it is loaned out. That's how banks make money, and why they pay you to deposit cash in the bank. They're not a charity, they want your cash so they can loan it out 9x to other people.

> selling short-term investments to make payroll

Payroll is usually met by establishing a "line of credit" with the local bank, because a business's revenue is not on the same schedule as its payroll obligations. Selling short-term investments to make payroll is inefficient (as you imply) but also quite unnecessary.

Re:Modeling a Wealth Tax by ChuckMcM on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @06:02PM (#24204870)
Sort of and sort of not. Companies do sit on cash. Their cash equivalent accounts are designed so that they can be reliably liquidated in under 30, 60, and 90 days and have no chance of a reduction in principal amount.

The kinds of "investments" that allows for are thus quite limited to things such as treasury bonds, certificates of deposit, and some very special case derivative instruments.

Those are not the sort of investments that build houses or get loaned out to businesses.

Re:Modeling a Wealth Tax by WalterBright on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @07:31PM (#24205563)
Cash equivalent accounts are NOT cash. The cash has been loaned out.

If you deposit $100 in the bank, you do NOT have cash in the bank. The bank loans it out 9 times over, that's right, your $100 turns into $900 of loans handed out to people and businesses who spend/invest it.

It's the magic of fractional reserve banking.

A massive clue that it is not idle cash is when interest is paid on the balance. That can only happen if the cash is "put to work", i.e. it is NOT cash.

Re:Modeling a Wealth Tax by ChuckMcM on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @07:48PM (#24205682)
That's true, but $100 in a series-E savings bond is just sitting around waiting for tax dollars to pay its coupon rate. Not really helping anyone and certainly not participating in the fractional reserve system (to the extent that the federal government runs such a system to its own advantage :-)).

When I helped set up one of these accounts for the startup I was in, we set it up to hold the $10 to $20 million that came in from investors. We bought t-bills through Goldman Sachs. They are very liquid, they pay a marginal return, and they are intrinsically insured. At most we kept $100K in our "regular" bank account[1] to pay salaries and taxes. Paying vendors consisted of simultaneously selling some t-bills, wiring the money to the vendor, and putting the fractional remain into the checking account.

[1] This was the FDIC insurance limit so we didn't hold more than that in a depository account.

Re:Modeling a Wealth Tax by WalterBright on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @08:00PM (#24205752)
The reason the government issues savings bonds is so they can spend the money used to buy them. The same for t-bills.

It is never sitting around as cash. Again, the fact that it pays interest is the clue that it is not cash, it has been spent "helping anyone".

Nowhere in your description is there money idly sitting around as cash.