Re:I fear App Review is getting too powerful (2015) [pdf]
by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:56PM
(#24191983)
Like I said, arbitrary line drawing. The only reason you can't do photo editing on a switch is that Nintendo hasn't approved a photo editing app on its store.
How is that really different than what Apple does?
Re:I fear App Review is getting too powerful (2015) [pdf]
by lelandbatey on Monday August 17, 2020 @06:51PM
(#24193207)
I have no expectation of using the controllers of my Nintendo Switch to slowly and arduously type out an email. It features input devices made exclusively to be great at playing games. I cannot "daily drive" a Nintendo switch even if Nintendo allowed me sideload whatever apps I want, because all it has are game controllers. Because of this, while technically it contains general purpose hardware, practically it is a game machine.
On an iPhone, I do expect to be able to do general purpose tasks because it's input methods allow me to conveniently do those general purpose tasks.
Re:I fear App Review is getting too powerful (2015) [pdf]
by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @09:05AM
(#24198086)
> I have no expectation of using the controllers of my Nintendo Switch to slowly and arduously type out an email.
As far as I am aware, there is no reason other than artificially imposed limitations that a Bluetooth or USB keyboard could not be connected to a Swtich.
It's the same thing, the manufacturer arbitrarily chose what functionality to allow and what not to allow.
A quick search for the term "general purpose device" gives me definitions such as the following:
With this definition in mind, I say that a general purpose device is one that you expect to be able to use for general computer tasks, factoring in the "out of the box" input and output methods included with that device. On a Roku, since I have only a simple remote, I do not expect to be able to write an email. However, on an iPhone, with it's touch screen keyboard, I do expect to be able to type out an email. Likewise, I don't expect to be able to edit pictures and video on a Nintendo switch (even though it can record pictures and video of games) since all you have are controllers, while on an iPhone I do expect to be able to edit videos and pictures. It is the breadth of tasks supported by the hardware and made easy by the input methods that make a device "general purpose".