News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by AnthonyMouse on Monday August 17, 2020 @02:59PM (#24190574)
> Should closed hardware (that owns its entire stack) even be legal to sell?

No.

> You can't argue that Prima Cinema should not be locked down (claiming anti-competitive behavior) because the paranoid film studios wouldn't even license their content if it wasn't.

You can actually. They demand this kind of DRM because they know the customer would sooner say yes to it than not get the movie. But that's only because they're in the better bargaining position as the only source for the movie -- it's leveraging the copyright monopoly into perfidious control over the device market. But they still, at the end of the day, want your money. Which means that if the thing they're insisting on is prohibited, they'll make it work without it.

Consider the general argument you're making. It's basically that if DRM was prohibited by law then Hollywood wouldn't distribute movies at all. But that's farcical -- they would have no revenue. Instead they would just distribute them without it, because they'd have no other option.

Okay, but what about your edge case, the really fancy one with the hardware anti-tampering. Wouldn't they at least not have that one? Still no, because it's still the same thing. The only point in having that is to try to push back the day when the movie is on all the pirate sites. But it's only to push it back while they're still distributing it using the higher margin distribution channels. If DRM was prohibited whatsoever then they couldn't use it there, so they would distribute it even there without it because otherwise there is no high margin early release market to protect.

Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by sudosysgen on Monday August 17, 2020 @03:32PM (#24190934)
Which makes me think, what prevents me from putting a lens in front to the projector and directly imaging the projection into a camera sensor? Modern cameras can record lossless 48bpp equiv. video in 4K, it would pretty much be a 1:1 copy given sufficiently sophisticated optics.

Which leads me to the conclusion that the only reason why no one is ripping movies using Prima Cinema projectors and commodity grade hardware is the price. If they removed DRM it wouldn't make much of a difference, the limiting factor is already the price of the projector.

Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by AnthonyMouse on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:08PM (#24191412)
I honestly think that DRM is very much like antivirus in the sense that the only reason anybody buys into it is that the companies who develop it pay sales reps to convince corporations that it's something they need when it's really just poisonous snake oil and paying money to someone to shoot you in the foot.
Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by kmeisthax on Monday August 17, 2020 @05:31PM (#24192425)
Well, there's some practical considerations - getting the refresh rate sync'd up, avoiding or filtering moire patterns out, getting the colors and such just right, things like that. However, it's possible enough that most theater projectors already have DRM restrictions that shut the system down if you start fiddling with the image path. The password to authorize an image path change is only handed out to supervisors. Evidently, access to such codes were so uncommon that, during the 3D movies era of last decade, most projectionists wouldn't bother swapping out 3D stereographic filters for 2D showings because it would require getting management involved.
Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by sudosysgen on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:53PM (#24193686)
Modern cameras will actually automatically sync their shutter rates to any flickering light sources. As for colors, they are designed to let you apply lookup-table based corrections by providing huge amounts of color information you can correct later.

Crucially, this approach wouldn't trigger anything because all of the equipment would work outside of the projector. You would add the lenses and camera aligned and just after the projector. In effect, the system would take the place of the screen in the image path. I don't know of any protected image screen that can detect tampering.

Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by josephcsible on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:13PM (#24191470)
The movies are probably watermarked, so they'd know who leaked them, and then sue the leakers for all they're worth.
Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by weehoo on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:16PM (#24191506)
This is how some video game demos are managed. Subtle color variations are used throughout the game window to uniquely finger print each copy of the game during media blackout.
Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by sudosysgen on Monday August 17, 2020 @07:55PM (#24193697)
Indeed. There are, however, ways around that.
Re:Apple, Epic, and the App Store by weehoo on Monday August 17, 2020 @04:15PM (#24191492)
I would be surprised if there wasn’t a theater projectionist in the warez scene that has a setup like the one you describe.

DRM is ridiculous because consuming the product is a side channel.