News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Predatory journal accepts fake story about scooters and h... by goto11 on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:45AM (#24186682)
The whole affair seem to thoroughly politicized. The results are presented as if "grievance studies" should be particularly prone to publishing hoax papers, but there is no control used as far as I can tell, so who knows if other studies or disciplines or better or worse? Medicine certainly also seems to be vulnerable. Maybe the whole of academia and research has a problem with peer review and bad-quality journals?

Science is different from satire. It is great satire to get a passage from Mein Kampf accepted by a feminist journal - but is it valid scientific research?

Re:Predatory journal accepts fake story about scooters and h... by unishark on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:30AM (#24187021)
I'd say his goal was clearly to make a political point, not a scientific discovery. But making political points is not unethical behavior.

As for the difference between science and satire, I think you missed my point. Which is that the argument is the same (i.e. mens rea, meaning intent to commit a crime), not the actual act.

Re:Predatory journal accepts fake story about scooters and h... by goto11 on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:35AM (#24187666)
Obviously "making a point" or "satire" is not a valid justification for scientific fraud. Otherwise anyone caught in plagiarism or whatever could just use that excuse to avoid consequences.

But if fraudulent or manipulated articles were used as part of legitimate research to study failures in the scientific system itself, it could be justified. But obviously it would have to be handled as serious research, itself peer reviewed and so on.

Re:Predatory journal accepts fake story about scooters and h... by unishark on Monday August 17, 2020 @10:51AM (#24187846)
> Obviously "making a point" or "satire" is not a valid justification for scientific fraud. Otherwise anyone caught in plagiarism or whatever could just use that excuse to avoid consequences.

This is not good logic. Of course anyone they can make the excuse. Just like they can claim they made a editing mistake. Just like a person committing murder can claim self-defense. It doesn't mean the defense is true or holds. Establishing whether some behaved unethically is just hard sometimes.

Re:Predatory journal accepts fake story about scooters and h... by goto11 on Tuesday August 18, 2020 @04:42AM (#24196479)
You are indeed correct, since he was actually fired.