Re:Web by Google (TM)
by JadeNB on Sunday August 16, 2020 @05:28PM
(#24181488)
> Well please propose a solution.
Personally I'd like to live under a much more European model of governance, but that, too, isn't perfect. (And, of course, one way to do that is to move to Europe. But this thread started not from a debate about the best place to live, but from my response to a post whose wording, "we figured it out ~250 years ago", could be read as suggesting that the US had found the right solution to government.)
But it is meaningful to disagree with "we figured it out ~250 years ago" (a quote from the post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24178311 to which I was originally responding), which says that we already know the answer, even if I don't know the answer (and even if, as I suspect, there isn't just one answer—if there is even one).
> good luck with research on fixing things like covid, ebola, and polio.
Polio is gone. Ebola, to the extent that it is gone, is because of a massive worldwide effort, not because of any one government—it literally, scientifically, could not have been eradicated by one government. It's not clear to me that the US's record on dealing with COVID is such that it can afford to sneer at anyone else's ability to deal with it, "anarchy enclave" or otherwise.
Personally I'd like to live under a much more European model of governance, but that, too, isn't perfect. (And, of course, one way to do that is to move to Europe. But this thread started not from a debate about the best place to live, but from my response to a post whose wording, "we figured it out ~250 years ago", could be read as suggesting that the US had found the right solution to government.)
But it is meaningful to disagree with "we figured it out ~250 years ago" (a quote from the post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24178311 to which I was originally responding), which says that we already know the answer, even if I don't know the answer (and even if, as I suspect, there isn't just one answer—if there is even one).
> good luck with research on fixing things like covid, ebola, and polio.
Polio is gone. Ebola, to the extent that it is gone, is because of a massive worldwide effort, not because of any one government—it literally, scientifically, could not have been eradicated by one government. It's not clear to me that the US's record on dealing with COVID is such that it can afford to sneer at anyone else's ability to deal with it, "anarchy enclave" or otherwise.