Re:The TikTok ban and the openness trap
by pessimizer on Saturday August 15, 2020 @10:27PM
(#24174350)
China isn't going to change for economic reasons because it is extremely successful economically. I wonder how the American psyche will be able to withstand the transition from demanding arbitrary sanctions on China for humanitarian reasons to demanding that China stop their sanctions on the US, also for humanitarian reasons.
Is calling for the release of a million Uyghurs from re-education camps an “arbitrary humanitarian reason”?
[dead]
That’s just empty whataboutism, a disingenuous form of discussion used to excuse atrocities. “Why are you singling out slavery in America, African tribes had slaves too!”
This was a thread about tiktok. Why did xinjiang come up in the first place?
People are obsessed with hating on China, and it's clearly based on national rivalry and a feeling of threat to america's position moreso than human rights.
[dead]
The difference is that except for the leftover Neocon vanguard of Bill Kristol and Max Boot, no one is actually saying the Iraq War was a good thing, and no one making a serious argument about that war's history is claiming that the US "set out to murder one million Iraqis". These kinds of takes are meant to be reductionist ploys used to excuse the behavior of PRC by implying that there is some kind of moral equivalency between these events, which are separated by half a planet (literally) of context. Also, it might be wise to speak with some people who lived under actual oppressive/authoritarian regimes - like the Taliban or the Soviet Union - before making a claim that living that way is always preferable to death.
Right. And you think people in the Chinese government set out to put a million Uyghurs in work camps while being criticized by the world? I’m sure it was done in the name of containing terrorism and extremism and it’s something they constantly justify to their population. Stop seeing China as some bogeyman.
I don't see China as a bogeyman. I see them as a rising power with global aims, and an explicit objective of suplanting the United States as the premier global power. It seems reasonable to ask questions about whether or not that is a good thing, both for the rest of the world and for the people of the United States. Fair?
Re:The TikTok ban and the openness trap
by free_rms on Saturday August 15, 2020 @10:22PM
(#24174315)
It's specifically a sign of weakness that we'd feel the need to engage in protectionism for social media. The only worse idea would be finance.
If we were talking about repatriating manufacturing and electronics, you could get me on board.
Re:The TikTok ban and the openness trap
by switch11 on Saturday August 15, 2020 @11:03PM
(#24174581)
this is beautifully put: Arbitrary action such as this is a sign of weakness: of economic weakness, and the fear to no longer be good enough to be the single biggest winner of free trade the US was for most of the 20th century.
Arbitrary action such as this is a sign of weakness: of economic weakness, and the fear to no longer be good enough to be the single biggest winner of free trade the US was for most of the 20th century. It's also a weakness of the law: of institutions competent and empowered to specifically define and litigate harmful behaviour, within the existing confines of law, such as due process. Instead, it's executive fiat, directed against foreign companies that have no lobby powerful enough to protect them, and coming from an office where nobody bothers to ask for reasonable explanations, because (last weakness) the guy is incapable, uninterested, and really just completely devoid of any understanding of the rule of law.
Americans already are losing as much as China is from this action. But its only in mindless entertainment that people won't complain about because they fear being mocked for enjoying such things. But if it works, the hits will start creeping closer, and you now need to make sure to stay not just on the right side of the law, but also the far-right side of politics.
Meanwhile, China isn't going to change for economic reasons: countries from cuba to North Korea to, for the longest time, the USSR have not budged in the face of sanctions. A country in the process of cutting off the lifeblood of its status as a superpower of science and entrepreneurship, just because people in rural counties that have never seen a foreigner have decided they don't like them, should really be in a good position to understand how powerless economic interests are against ideology and jingoism.