Re:An Engineer's Explanation of the Fukushima Incident
by Tobias42 on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @06:09PM
(#2417204)
Do you know if new plants are generally built with containments that work without cooling?
Re:An Engineer's Explanation of the Fukushima Incident
by Tuna-Fish on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @07:18PM
(#2417419)
No. The new reactors under construction are mostly very conservative and traditional Gen III+ PWR designs, with some added safety features. The reactors that can survive complete loss of cooling are all Gen IV designs, that are currently under discussion, not construction.
Re:An Engineer's Explanation of the Fukushima Incident
by VladRussian on Thursday April 07, 2011 @04:01PM
(#2421000)
>You can only remove the energy actively until these short-lived products decay to the point where air cooling is sufficient to keep them at a safe temperature.
this is my point - necessity for active removal of energy.
The closest thing to what i was talking about seems to be molten salt reactors where energy producing reaction goes only when salt is pumped through the core/moderator. If something goes wrong - the valves open and the salt is dumped [gravitationally] into the tanks which can be large enough to allow for passive air cooling of the secondary decay energy.
Fukushima, however, has a negative void coefficient. Moreover, the fission reaction was stopped immediately after the earthquake successfully by the automatic insertion of control rods. The heat that is being generated is from short-lived fission products (ie, nuclear waste) undergoing spontaneous decay events, thus producing heat (but only a small fraction of the heat of an active reactor).
It is physically impossible to design a reactor in which such spontaneous decay can be stopped. You can only remove the energy actively until these short-lived products decay to the point where air cooling is sufficient to keep them at a safe temperature. You can, however, design a reactor in which the passive containment structures can withstand the temperatures of fresh waste material with no active cooling; however such technology was not available at the time the Fukushima plants were built.