Re:SEC Enforcement of Insider Trading Dropped to Lowest Poin...
by Galanwe on Saturday August 15, 2020 @05:26AM
(#24167406)
_IANAL, but have been working in HF for the past 10 years, with quarterly compliance/regulatory trainings, where I asked numerous questions to lawyers about the subject._
That would not count as insider trading.
For insider trading regulation to kick in, you need to prove the information given carried substantial certainty about the outcome of the trade.
A wink is definitely not substantial certainty. In your situation, the CEO would have to clearly communicate information that led to a positive trade.
Someone explained to me once how ambiguous it can be. Let's say we have CEO and his Friend talking together in speech, in real life:
Friend: "Hey CEO! How are things going at company :)"
CEO: "Oh, things are going well."
Friend: "Oh yeah? Is it looking good?"
CEO: "Yes! ;) Looking really good" winks
Friend buys stocks, Press Release comes out, and Friend holds onto the stock for some quarters.
Here you can see that CEO gave a wink and said things are going really good. He could have not winked, he could have said things are going fine. He can also not communicate this over-optimistically with other people.